In the past few months I’ve alluded to the disappearance and the far-reaching implications to some of society’s institutions: the two-parent family, organized religion, education as we once knew it, and now to the two mainstays of American political life: the Democrats and the Republicans.
If this trend continues, a new verse about the demise of the two-party political system may need to be added to the traditional Pete Seeger folk song, “Where Have All the Flowers Gone?” The song’s ending should still remain the same: “When will they ever learn?”
Or more importantly, what should we learn about the ever-shifting sands beneath our political affiliations?
First, the numbers. According to the Nevada Secretary of State’s voter registration trends from 2000 to 2023, Democrats in Nevada enjoyed their highest share of registration numbers in 2008, with 44% of voters being Democrat. Republicans reached their highest percentage of voter market share when the GOP enjoyed 41.6% of voters in 2002.
The latest Nevada voter registration numbers in 2023 find that statewide, Democrats are now at 30.9%, and Republicans are now at 28.7%. The most alarming number (at least to the Donkey and Elephant organizations) is the 40.4% of Nevada registered voters who are now either nonpartisans or members of smaller political parties. To put those trends in perspective, the two political parties might take a cue from troubadour Bob Dylan’s 1960s tune: “The Times They Are A-Changin’.” And while the question may be eluding the established political entities as to why, they are increasingly faced with the dilemma Dylan sang about: “Admit that the waters (nonpartisan voter registration numbers) have grown and accept it that soon you’ll be drenched to the bone” (or become a minority, as has happened in Nevada).
Some are already measuring the rising ride of voter dissatisfaction with the two traditional political parties. Doug Goodman is the executive director of Nevadans for Election Reform. The way Goodman sees it, “Voters abandoning both the Democratic and Republican parties is not a new phenomenon. Since 2000, the Democratic Party has lost 11 percent voter share, the Republican Party 13 percent, while nonpartisan voter share has increased 19 percent, and when combined with minor party registration, 24 percent.”
What then are the reasons why voters are leaving both the Democrats and the Republicans?
First, the Democrats. A new book by political historians John Judis and Roy Teixeria, titled, “Where Have All the Democrats Gone?,” explains why. The authors argue Democrats “have steadily lost the allegiance of ‘everyday Americans’ — the working-and middle-class voters that were at the core of the older New Deal coalition … We can see in the polling data that’s been collected in the last year or two that the weaknesses of Democrats among non-white voters, particularly Hispanic and Black working-class voters, is pretty significant.”
It does seem to many critics that Democratic Party concerns have become less about the working class and more about the priorities of their base voters in the urban metro areas where culturally liberal white college graduates and elite professionals have been dominant in shaping Democrat policies.
Just as ultraconservatives on the far right have alienated more traditional Republicans in the GOP, far left progressives and their cultural radicalism have been alienating working class voters on four key issues: race, immigration, transgender rights and climate. As Texiera said in an interview in the Wall Street Journal, “I think when Democrats lost track of who these voters really were and started putting them into these boxes that corresponded to their ‘faculty-lounge politics view of the world,’ as James Cardwell once put it. I think they really started to lose some of these voters and will continue to lose them.”
As for the Republicans, they have a numbers problem as well. Longtime GOP strategist Karl Rove, who is now vilified by conservatives in his own party for being a “RINO” (Republican In Name Only), has pointed out that his party is losing suburban voters who were once the party’s main pillar of support: “We’ve got to be worried about what’s happening in the suburbs. We get wiped out in the Dallas suburbs, Houston suburbs, Chicago suburbs, Denver suburbs — you know there’s a pattern. When we start to lose in the suburbs, it says something to us.”
Even a number of Ronald Reagan conservatives are disillusioned with the “exclusive” as opposed to the “inclusive” nature of their political party. Former conservative radio talk-show host and author of “How The Right Lost Its Mind,” Charles Sykes puts it, “A lot of Republicans who believed in Reagan’s legacy are saddened by the abandonment of respect for gradualism, civility, expertise, intelligence and prudence — making many of them into political orphans — or nonpartisans.”
States like Nevada have lost voters in the political center — both independents and many Republicans who are uneasy with many of the exclusionary positions taken by leaders of the party. Successful politics, after all, is about addition — not subtraction.
Having been the Assembly minority leader in Carson City when Republicans won a onetime majority in every constitutional office and both legislative houses in 2014, I too, was branded a RINO by who those who considered I was too moderate for their liking. Like many others who have left the party, I obliged them. Those alt-right members of the GOP can no longer label me a RINO, because I am not one. I’m no longer a Republican, but a nonpartisan voter.
Therein lies the dilemma many Nevada voters now find themselves in. Our infatuation with a two-party system —something that the Founding Fathers did not include in the Constitution — has forced the electorate and its representatives to bow to one of two party principles in rhetoric, if not in fact, adding to the growing number of citizens who feel their views are being ignored. Large numbers of Nevadans are stranded on a homeless island in the middle of a political nowhere.
The abandonment of their former political homes has also contributed to the way a majority of Americans feel about 2024’s likely two presidential candidates. Right now, both Biden and Trump are in a “dislikability” dead heat, according to RealClearPolitics polling. A recent Associated Press/NORC poll found the most common words voters use to describe Biden are “old/outdated/aging/elderly” and Trump’s are “corrupt/criminal/crooked.” According to national pollster and focus-group guru Frank Luntz, “60% of American voters are looking for someone other than Biden or Trump.”
This unaffiliated momentum can be seen in Nevada, where those voters make up nearly a third of the state’s electorate. Nonpartisanship is even on November’s ballot here in the form of Question 3, which asks voters if they want to change to an open primary system, where unaffiliated voters can vote for a Republican or a Democrat without declaring a party.
Southern Nevada history professor Sondra Cosgrove agrees.
“Las Vegas draws thousands of visitors every year because it offers a range of experiences to match every walk of life,” she says. “The two political parties could learn something from the entertainment capital of the world, but instead, both sides are hunkering down around a narrow style of politics that alienates the majority of voters.”
So, where are all the voters going? Somewhere. Where that somewhere becomes depends on what you want the future to be.
Your thoughts? Email them to tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
