Just as it’s impossible to know what came first, the chicken or the egg, it’s equally hard to decide which of the two things caused the other when it comes to the relationship between violence and guns in America.

Questions about the origins of poultry’s existence and whether guns are causing the current levels of violence may appear to some to get us nowhere. To me, it’s worth looking at the various shades of gray in such matters — especially when the black-and-white-only arguments of both sides of the gun control issue have us faced off like a sheriff and an outlaw about to draw on each other, ready to send the loser of the “shootout” to an early grave.

While it’s true, as the National Rifle Association has famously said; “Guns don’t kill people, people do.” It’s equally true that people with guns kill people, and far more efficiently than people without them — So efficiently, more Americans died of gun-related injuries in 2021 than in any other year on record, according to the latest available statistics from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. It’s also a sad fact that guns have now become the leading cause of death of children and teens in the United States.

Complicating those statistics is the fact that suicides, which tend to attract less attention than murders and mass shootings, have long accounted for the majority of U.S. gun deaths. It’s harder to make the argument that “guns” cause suicides in the case of troubled persons, and not the person’s troubles themselves.

Regarding the relationship between violence and weapons, it may be less a paradox than the chicken and the egg. The rash of horrendous school shootings in locations too numerous to list prompted a new study by the Educational Fund to Stop Gun Violence to conclude: “More than two-thirds of mass shootings are domestic violence incidents or are perpetrated by shooters with a history of domestic violence.” Such problems aren’t exclusively caused by domestic violence, but they often stem out of the domestic environment troubled shooters grow up in.

Consider a joint federal study showing that 63 percent of youth suicides are from fatherless homes; as often as not, mass shooters are simultaneously suicidal. Robert Sampson, a Harvard sociologist, has observed that urban violence is concentrated in neighborhoods with mostly single-parent homes. A Michigan State University study found 75 percent of examined adolescent murderers were from fatherless homes. The Centers for Disease Control says 85 percent of children with behavioral disorders have only a mother in the home.

There is also the factor of violent video games and other social media enticements. In 2014, a local school shooting took place at Sparks Middle School. It was very personal for me. I was out of the country when I heard the sketchy details. My oldest daughter was a school counselor at Sparks Middle at the time the shooting took place. That day, 12 year-old Jose Reyes took an unlocked gun from his family’s kitchen and shot and killed teacher Michael Landsberry, and injured two students before killing himself.

The RGJ’s Siobhan McAndrew later reported: “Police described (about Reyes) a boy who owned violent video games, used the family’s laptop to search for things including bullying, and to look up ‘Top 10 evil children’ and a ‘Super Columbine Massacre Role Playing Game.'”

Troubled individuals aside, gun ownership in the country is on the rise. In what many consider a sacred principle enshrined in the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution of “the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.” One of the things proponents of that the Second Amendment say it does is to protects the right of self-defense. A study on gun ownership in the U.S. by the Pew Research Center found that “Two-thirds of gun owners cite protection as a major reason for owning a gun.”

RGJ readers who have contacted me for this piece made points like, “The majority, if not all, of the shootings in America are carried out by criminals or other nefarious individuals. Making the good guys helpless will not make the bad guys harmless.” Actor James Earl Jones agrees: “The world is filled with violence. Because criminals carry guns, we decent law-abiding citizens should also have guns. Otherwise, they will win and the decent people will lose.”

An example of that also hit close to home for me. UNR student Amanda Collins was a neighbor and a constituent of mine when I was in the Nevada Assembly. Unable to carry a firearm for protection while on campus, concealed- carry permit holder Collins was raped on the UNR campus by James Biela, a local construction worker who then went on to rape and murder another female student in Reno, Brianna Denison. It haunts Amanda to this day that had she been able to have her concealed firearm with her on the night of her rape, she may not only have stopped Biela from attacking her — but prevented the death of Brianna.

My efforts in the Legislature to give law-abiding students like Amanda that chance to protect themselves failed, but I was proud to co-sponsor legislation with the late Senator Debbie Smith requiring DNA samples on persons arrested on felony charges. Denison’s family say Brianna would be alive today had James Biela’s DNA from Amanda Collins been able to be examined. James Biela currently sits on death row in Nevada as his case is appealed.

How do we thread this difficult political needle without further tearing us apart? The battle over the Second Amendment has turned into a kind of proxy battle over the greater culture wars that are going on in this country. While guns are not what are causing the alarming rates of violent crimes in this country, they certainly make them bloodier. As comedian Robin Williams pointed out, “The Second Amendment says we have the right to bear arms, not to bear artillery.”

So, what can be done? We can look at support for measures that take a look at actual behavior disqualifying individuals for gun ownership. Deny gun ownership to felons, violent domestic offenders and dangerously mentally ill persons, and improve safe-storage measures. Behavior-based “red flag” laws are a good place to start.

As Second Amendment supporter and otherwise liberal author David French has said, “Democrats, stop trying all or nothing … Why not go for attainable reform? We don’t have to crack down on the Second Amendment to do something really meaningful about gun deaths in this country.”

“Republicans have to stop with maximum resistance to any reforms … how many times do we have to see somebody who’s obviously not fit to own a weapon be able to so easily purchase one and then go in immediately commit murder with it?”

Let’s stop with all the bumper-sticker logic.

As far back as the Garden of Eden, violence has reared its ugly head. Cain killed his brother Abel because of domestic resentments and did so with the first available weapon — allegedly the jawbone of an ass — and not a gun.

The amount of weapons in this country is a big problem. More so are the personal problems of too many Americans who resort to using them as James Biela and even Cain did. What are the causes and what are the effects are questions worth pondering and acting upon. No chicken or the egg here. Just our challenge as a human family on this planet.

Please shoot me your thoughts: pathickey@dataclonemail.com.

“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.