The first presidential debate (and possibly the only one) of the 2024 election cycle is about a week away. The political clash of aging titans, Joe Biden and Donald Trump, will be televised Wednesday, June 27, on CNN’s re-creation of the Roman Colosseum, minus a rip-roaring audience.
The strictly regulated debate with muted microphones and flashing red lights feels like a contest between two old gladiators getting ready to rumble — with both men hoping not to stumble politically, or even literally.
Whether or not this will be one of the most watched presidential debates in American history remains to be seen. A record-breaking audience of 84 million people watched the first 2016 presidential debate between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton.
Of course, we’ve seen Biden and Trump go at it before in 2020. That was four years ago and the deep personal animosity between the two has grown only stronger. Both campaign camps are hoping most of the political wounds from the televised debate will be self-inflicted. Trump’s handlers are hoping people will see “Biden being Biden,” while those in Joe’s corner are hoping voters simply view “Trump being Trump.”
While millions of Americans will tune in to see a colosseum-like spectacle; many may not actually “turn out” when Election Day comes. The ensuing drama and complicated issues with both men — Biden’s age and competency, and Trump’s strong-man peculiarities — appear to be turning off a growing number of American voters.
In a recent Newsweek article entitled “America Could See Surge in People Not Voting,” the author cites a CBS News poll conducted in June that found “only 80 percent of respondents said they will vote in November.” A similar poll in 2020 found that 89 percent planned to vote in the upcoming election.
Anthony Fowler, a professor of public policy at the University of Chicago, told Newsweek, “Americans may be less interested in voting this year because Biden and Trump are both historically controversial and unpopular candidates.”
Many voters, particularly moderates and independents (myself included), are disappointed with our options. The growing hyperpartisanship and win-by-any-means methods have created a toxic culture of self-serving political interests that have left many average Americans dismayed.
Voter registration numbers in Nevada mirror the fact that major party affiliation has been on a downward trajectory. The proportion of Americans who consider themselves political independents has been on the rise. The proportion of Americans who identify as independents now registers at about 43 percent, according to Gallup, while only about 27 percent of Americans identify as Republican and another 27 percent as Democrats.
Could anything short of a meteor shower taking out both presidential candidates — as my friend half-jokingly prays for — actually change the course of the 2024 election? Well, there is still such a thing as political conventions. Both major political parties have their nominating ceremonies coming up; the Republicans in Milwaukee in July, and the Democrats in Chicago in August.
Could there possibly be such an “unconventional” political convention where participants vote to change the rules and unbind delegates to vote for an alternative candidate? Might something unexpected happen? Stranger things have taken place in history.
Once upon a time, conventions mattered. They chose the candidates, often with plenty of intrigue and horse-trading in the notorious “smoke-filled rooms” of yesteryear. And for that reason, some memorable conventions have changed the politics of history.
As political commentator Jeff Greenfield of ABC News said speaking about past national conventions: “Throughout most of American history, in fact, raucous and mercurial gatherings were the rule rather than the exception.”
Since I’m neither a Republican nor a Democrat, it’s not for me to say that either party should decide not to “dance with the one who brung you.” But with polls consistently showing that Americans are overwhelmingly dissatisfied with both major party candidates, we’re starting to hear voices within both political camps about the advisability of dumping their nominee.
Democrat election data guru and founder of FiveThirtyEight Nate Silver suggested this past week that President Biden’s latest disapproval ratings might be enough cause for the Democratic front-runner to drop out of the 2024 presidential election. Silver points out on the fact that President Biden “just hit a new all-time low in approval (37.4%). Dropping out would be a big risk. But there’s some threshold below which continuing to run is a bigger risk. Are we there yet? I don’t know. But it’s more than fair to ask.”
Biden’s greatest liability (besides whatever you think of his policies) is his age. To put it plainly, most voters don’t believe Joe Biden can possibly make it as the U.S. president for another four years. Might it not be wiser, especially if Biden falters in the upcoming debate, to do the unconventional thing at the Democratic National Convention — and nominate someone else? Yes, it would turn over the apple cart big-time. But it might just save a presidency that most voters, including many of his own party think, may be their only chance of winning.
Sometimes the impossible becomes possible — especially when it seems like in this case, the possibility of Biden being re-elected is becoming increasingly problematic. Democrats might even win, if they did something they are very unlikely to do.
What is also virtually impossible is for Republicans to nominate someone other than Donald Trump. Is it possible that Trump could change his bombastic rhetoric, his petty name-calling, and insistence on making everything about him? What if Trump stood on the convention stage in Milwaukee and said, “I’m a changed man.” Impossible, you say? You’re in all likelihood right. Almost 80-year-old billionaires with inflated egos don’t typically have the propensity for personal change. Polls consistently show Republicans would have won in a landslide if they had replaced Trump with another candidate. This, of course, is about as likely as my friend’s meteor theory.
Therein lies the perplexing conundrum that many Nevada voters find themselves in. They are left with a choice between two aging combative candidates who seem hell-bent on selling the narrative, “I’m better than the other guy, because he is so much worse than I am.”
While it’s true that politics at times does make for strange bedfellows, it also can produce empty beds. A number of voters I know don’t want to get under the political covers with either of these two elderly combatants. Sadly, whichever of the two men wins, the country is likely to remain seriously divided.
It’s the reason I worry that many Nevadans won’t bother to vote in November, or pick the one option voters in the Silver State still have — “None of these Candidates.” I hold out hope this isn’t the case.
For myself, I’ll stick with what the original Robert Kennedy said: “Some men see things as they are and ask, ‘Why?’ I dream of things that never were and ask, ‘Why not?'”
I wonder why we can’t do better this election year as Americans. Being always set to rumble because the other side is something to be feared makes for epic gladiator-like battles — but not for better candidates, or a better country.
We can be better than this as Americans, even if our presidential candidates are not. Email me: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
