Politics is about deciding winners and losers. In a political world dominated by men with super-charged egos, election year battles frequently come down to candidates attempting to make themselves look better by making their opponents look worse.
The result? An American electorate that feels fed up with all the bickering and one-upmanship that dominates our never-ending campaign seasons. A recent study by the Pew Research Center’s American Trends Panel found that with less than a year before the presidential election, “nearly two-thirds of Americans (65%) say they feel exhausted when thinking about politics, while 55% feel angry.”
Would a change to a women-centered brand of politics make a difference? Nevadans may have quietly thought so in 2019, when they elected the first female majority state legislature in the country. According to Nevada’s Legislative Counsel Bureau, “women make up a record 62 percent of the Legislature overall — and for the first time — hold a majority of seats in both legislative houses.”
One notable female leader, Margaret Thatcher, the first woman British Prime Minister (1979-1990), famously said, “In politics, if you want anything said, ask a man. If you want anything done, ask a woman.” She also made the point that women have certain emotional capabilities that serve to bring together a nation at a time of need. Remarking about female-centered leadership: “Any woman who understands the problems of running a home will be nearer to understanding the problems of running a country.” Margaret Thatcher was that towering figure who had the strength of both a motherly matron and an independent maverick.
When women have been needed to be a trailblazer and play an outsized role in state politics, a couple of well-known Nevadans come to mind: Jill Derby and Amy Tarkanian. Both women live in the Carson Valley. One is a Democrat. The other is a Republican. Both have been state chairwomen of their respective political parties. Both mothers, each has been a groundbreaker — unorthodox in style, and not short on substance.
Jill Derby
Jill Derby is a fourth-generation Nevadan from Lovelock. She traveled the world as a young woman before gaining a Ph.D. in cultural anthropology. Raised as a “Goldwater Republican,” Jill became “a realigned progressive” and eventually, a Democratic Party leader.
Living in conservative Carson Valley in the 1970s, Jill spearheaded “Nevadans for ERA” (the Equal Rights Amendment). As a result, she was asked to run for the Nevada Assembly in GOP-dominated Douglas County where it’s joked Democrats there could all fit in a phone booth (if we still had such things).
By going to door-to-door to ranches and genuinely listening to her would-be constituents, Jill nearly pulled off the upset of the century in local Nevada politics. On election night, Reno TV stations reported on her surprising win over Lou Bergevin, only to have them correct themselves the following morning once Republican absentee ballots were counted. Talking about her near-miss success, Jill says, “Personal connections and likability can eclipse party and policy differences.”
Dr. Derby went on to serve from 1988 to 2006 as an elected regent for the Nevada System of Higher Education, serving three terms as board chair. As regent, Jill attempted to mediate and soften the departure from the UNLV Rebels of legendary basketball coach Jerry Tarkanian, saying she had wanted to find “a middle ground resolution to a highly emotional battle between two entrenched sides in which compromise seemed impossible.”
Speaking about her approach to conflict-resolution, Jill says, “Women are more drawn to working on the interpersonal level. I don’t like to see anybody lose. I didn’t want ‘Tark’ to be humiliated by the outcome.”
Speaking about the current state of today’s politics, Derby told me, “Politics is supposed to be the art of the compromise. People are too dug into their political party identities. My way or the highway doesn’t work in institutions where policy is needed to move society forward.”
Reflecting on her life and journey as a Nevada political trailblazer in her recently published book by the University of Nevada Press, “When You Dare to Say Yes,” Jill reflects on the unique qualities women bring to public life: “Women, with their inclination to consultive leadership and the use of soft power, bring a much-needed perspective to the body politic.”
Amy Tarkanian
When Amy Tarkanian moved with husband Danny to the Carson Valley, Jill Derby was the first person she called on. Derby said about the time these two old friends have shared: “Amy and I were on the campaign trail together for years. She’s a smart can-do, make-a-difference women. She and I rarely agree on policy issues, but we have a great time discussing them together.”
Simply put, you can call these two women friends — something that once happened frequently in Carson City and Washington, D.C. circles before hyperpartisanship subdivided us all.
Amy is married to the son of the controversial UNLV coach Jill tried to help. Danny Tarkanian is a conservative Republican candidate who’s ran for numerous political offices in Nevada, finally becoming a commissioner in Douglas County.
Mother of four children, Amy also has stuck her oar in the turbulent waters of Nevada politics. She served as the youngest Republican state chair in the nation in 2011. Her influence extended to the national stage as a delegate representing Nevada for Donald Trump at the 2016 Republican National Convention in Cleveland. Amy is a frequent guest and media pundit on numerous national media shows.
Like Jill, Amy has the pedigree and the chops of an independent-minded maverick. Tarkanian got herself into hot water recently with GOP officials when she endorsed Democratic State Treasurer Zach Conine over Republican nominee Michele Fiore. Tarkanian explained at the time that her cross-party endorsement of Conine was because the scandal-plagued Fiore “should not be anywhere near the state’s finances.”
Talking about her time as party chairwoman, Amy says, “Unlike today, I didn’t reject people who came into the party — I welcomed them. I was a big-tent person, not a purist, when it came to being a Republican.” Asked about the growth of nonpartisan and independent voter registration numbers in Nevada, Amy says, “Many lifelong Republicans feel like they are floating in a raft looking for a place to call home.”
Like Jill Derby, Amy sees the role of woman in today’s combative political environment as essential. “Women have direct and very personal ties to the economy and the needs of families. Women are often better at delegating and multitasking than men.”
Showing her conservative side: “I believe in the right person at the right time is what’s needed today, regardless of gender.”
Regardless of their gender, Nevada has been fortunate to have two leaders like Jill and Amy. As Jill wrote in the conclusion of her memoir, “Nevada, with its smaller population, allowed me the opportunity to step up, stand out, and be heard.”
These two notable Nevada women have done just that. Though from different sides of the political aisle, they both represent what has been best about the Silver State: independence, inclusiveness and commitment to statesmanship — or “stateswomanship,” if you allow me to concoct a new term.
Future leaders can learn a treasure-store of lessons from the likes of Jill Derby and Amy Tarkanian. Nevada would be a better place for those who take note, whether they be young women, or young men.
Let me know your thoughts: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
