Sparks flew in Philadelphia on Tuesday night at the site of the second presidential debate. And while darkness has descended on the evening’s blistery exchange between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris, the embers are still smoldering beneath the surface.
The smoke and mirrors of the debate stage may have shut down for the time being, but the emotions of a divided American public are forecast to usher in the equivalent of a political Red Flag Warning. It seems about as certain to happen as the horrendous wind gusts fueling the expansion of the Davis Fire.
Tuesday’s fiery debate was best summarized by The Free Press’s Eli Lake as a night where “Trump Took the Bait. Harris Kept Her Cool.” As the Wall Street Journal editorialized, “She won the debate because she came in with a strategy to taunt and goad Mr. Trump into diving down rabbit holes of personal grievance and vanity that left her policies and history largely untouched.”
Solitude and fellowship
Disappointed by the best (or the worst) of what both presidential candidates had to say, I decided to take a late-night drive to Reno’s aptly named Windy Hill Scenic Overlook on Lakeside Drive. I was joined by other sleepless Reno residents worried about the state of the blaze that’s threatening to engulf parts of our growing community and our beloved natural landscape. It was eerily quiet seeing little or no signs of flames beneath the moonlight sky. It seemed each of us was worrying about what awaits the region in the days ahead.
In a similar way, I worry about what awaits America — before and after the 2024 election. With today’s fickle voting public and a troubled international situation that at any moment could turn into the equivalent of what local fire officials have called a “PDS” (particularly dangerous situation), many Americans have more than a little to worry about.
It’s impossible to know who will win in November.
“We’re never going to get what we want from polling this year — a definitive answer on who is going to win,” Larry Sabato from the University of Virginia’s Center for Politics recently wrote. “2024 is a highly competitive election, and polling has too many challenges to be a reliable gauge in the close swing states (like Nevada).”
However, it’s not hard to predict that the press and their influencers in social media will fan the flames of bitterness and accusations that characterized both candidate’s approach to each other on debate night in birthplace of the Constitution.
Whether Donald Trump’s relatively bad performance, or Kamala Harris’s relatively better one, will swing whatever undecided voters are still out there within such a divided electorate, remains to be seen.
“When it comes to voter choices, research has generally suggested little impact from watching debates,” wrote Dustin Carnahan, an associate professor at Michigan State University. “Debate viewers tend to be among the most politically engaged and thereby likely to have their minds made up well before the debate. For these people, debates serve largely as a spectator sport, watched mainly to see how one’s preferred candidate performs and with little to no effect on their opinions of the candidates.”
Will debate matter?
Still, a lopsided debate performance can have a lasting effect on a candidate’s prospects for success. Witness Joe Biden. In light of many Republicans feeling ABC’s moderators were favorably disposed towards Harris and against their candidate, it may be a reason for Trump to accept Harris’s challenge for a second debate between the two on FOX in October. Personally, I’ll be surprised if a second debate ever happens.
A growing number of Americans are viewing politics as a chronic stressor that triggers negative emotions that leave them exhausted. A recent Wall Street Journal story, “No Politics Allowed,” details how some Americans are avoiding politics at all costs: “They are canceling subscriptions, deleting apps, silencing notifications and unfollowing rabble-rousers. Many wanted no part of Tuesday night’s presidential debate or its fallout.”
Stanford political scientist Morris Fiorina talks about the reasons for political gridlock from such a divided electorate: “The increased polarization between the Democratic and Republican parties has made for bad politics. Democrats have become more consistently liberal and Republicans more consistently conservative.”
And while the two parties and their appointed candidates are hopelessly divided and at each other’s throats, figuratively speaking, the broader American public is not. It’s why our presidential candidates would be wise to temper the rhetoric of personal disdain for each other. It’s why there is the growing number of Americans in the middle who wish both sides would listen to and accept the concerns on the other side of the political aisle.
Come together
As I’ve said many times in this column, I’m more worried about what’s going to happen in the country after the Nov. 5 election more than I am about the campaign season leading up to it. Both presidential candidates seem convinced that if the other person wins, it’s all over, literally, for America. Both want us to believe that this is not just the most important election of our lifetime (which we’ve heard a million times); that it may very well be America’s last election.
I refuse to accept that. I would rather see Americans do what Northern Nevadans are doing in the face of an unprecedented wildfire crisis at our doorstep. The only way to protect life, property and our pine tree limbs is for the public and government agencies to trust each other and work together to preserve all that is near and dear to us.
Good analogy or not, the same can be said for the country. As Eleanor Roosevelt once said, “It is better to light a candle than curse the darkness.” It may take a kind of a miracle to avoid some of the devastation heading our way, but, miracles are more likely to take place when there is faith among the would-be recipients.
One thing does seem certain: It’s going take more light than heat to get us through any impending crisis ahead.
In the case of the Davis fire, it’s taking a united community in support of those making decisions and sacrifices on the front lines of the blaze.
In the case of the American political situation, it may take more than scripted debate performances to curse the darkness that threatens the stability of our democratic republic. It will take as Martin Luther King once suggested: “Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.”
Love for our cherished nation requires us to soften our attacks on our political foes and embrace the one thing that can help us settle many of our differences — a love of country and our fellow Americans.
What say you? Email me at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
