The war in the Mideast is not just a battle between Israel and Hamas. It’s a clash between two worldviews with distinct sets of moral and political values. One side thinks people with different beliefs can co-exist in a community of nations on this planet. The other believes nations must adhere to their totalitarian doctrine, or be eliminated from the face of the earth.
This current war, although it’s not literally touched the borders of either country, should be understood as a clash between Iran and the United States. Just as the war in Ukraine is little more than a proxy for Russia challenging free democracies in the West, as well as China’s threatened invasion of Taiwan — nothing more than its first move in a geopolitical chess game by the communist giant in the East, hoping to first run the board in Asia, and one day the world.
Young Americans especially should log off social media’s China-founded TikTok long enough to see “the forest for the trees” when it comes to an increasingly dangerous world. According to a Harvard/Harris poll, 51 percent of Americans ages 18–24 believe Hamas was justified in its brutal Oct. 7 terrorist attacks on Israeli citizens.
Really, Hamas was “justified” in committing atrocities like burned bodies, decapitated babies, raped women, children tied together with their parents, and mutilated corpses?
Watching pro-Hamas rallies on elite campuses and outside the White House celebrating Hamas’s murderous cause, it makes me worry that Americans are forgetting their history, and in the process losing their soul.
American historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr. wrote, “The genius of America lies in its capacity to forge a single nation from peoples of remarkably diverse racial, religious, and ethnic origins … The American creed envisages a nation composed of individuals making their own choices and accountable to themselves … It is what all Americans should learn, because it is what binds all Americans together.”
Take for instance; freedom of speech, association and faith — a hallmark of American democracy enshrined in our First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
American university students on many of America’s elite campuses who are supporting Hamas (and therefore its mullah mentors in Iran) should take a look at what both Israel and Iran say and practice with regards to diverse beliefs and the freedom of conscience.
The Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel “will ensure complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex; it will guarantee freedom of religion, conscience, language, education and culture.” In Iran, the Constitution states: “Publications and the press have freedom of expression except when it is detrimental to the fundamental principles of Islam or the rights of the public” (which are of course determined by the Islamic state).
Try holding a multicultural music festival with scantily dressed concertgoers in Iran like the one students were killed and kidnapped at on the day Hamas attacked Israel. Do protestors supporting Hamas believe the Islamic fundamentalists they are supporting would allow such gatherings in a country they would create in Palestine?
Recently, more than 30 Harvard student groups published a statement saying they held “the Israeli regime entirely responsible for all unfolding violence.” Some of those same students groups have attacked Jewish students for posting photos of slain Israeli hostages.
UNLV’s Boyd professor of law, Sylvia Lazos, recently wrote, “Tearing down someone else’s property is not protected by the First Amendment. Does tearing down posters of hostages erase the horror of Hamas, or minimize the suffering of Israeli families? We need conversations headed by professors, not protests.”
For all that freedom of speech guarantees, it does not give license to crimes, nor is it without certain consequences. It’s no wonder that some major donors are beginning to withdraw their financial support from many of America’s elite universities.
It’s also ironic that America’s First Amendment supports and protects Americans to disagree with a president’s foreign policy and to support of a cause that would abhor that very freedom. It was the wisdom of America’s founders that both allowed and celebrated such a conspicuous irony.
As Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Jon Meacham writes in “The Soul of America,” “The measure of our political and cultural health cannot be whether we all agree on all things at all times. We don’t and we won’t. Disagreement and debate — including ferocious disagreement and exhaustive debate — are hallmarks of American politics.”
It why Muslim-Americans can support an Hamas-backed Palestinian state that would never allow such a protest of a government of their own making. We live in a society that allows for dissent. The pro-Hamas protestors are fighting for a cause that would disallow their very protests.
Still, the First Amendment must remain neutral, now matter how wrong are the causes that benefit from it. As legendary Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. said, “If there is any principle of the Constitution … it is the principle of free thought — not free thought for those who agree with us, but freedom for the thought that we hate.”
And so, I both laugh and cry when I see young Americans support a cause I hate, and know they would too — if they ever had to live under it.
All of which leads me to side with Jon Meacham “that America’s fate is contingent upon whether hope or fear emerges triumphant.” I pray it’s hope that conquers my present fears. I hope new leadership emerges in this country and abroad.
While I’m a member of the Baby Boomer generation itself, I hope our next president in this country is not a Boomer or a member of the “Silent Generation.” It’s time for a new generation of leadership. Not only in America, but in the Arab and Israeli countries of the Mideast, in oligarchical Russia, and in totalitarian Communist China. Younger leaders with a fresh view of the world deserve their crack at leading us out of the mess that’s been created.
While the sky appears cloudy in most parts of our world, the sun awaits to shine behind our current gloominess. Rainbows appear through the clouds to prove as much, as the one did this morning when I stepped out on my Reno porch to see what I thought was a storm.
America has been a multicolored rainbow of freedom shinning over a stormy world full of dictators and tyrants. It’s time for that light to re-emerge. As Martin Luther King said, “The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”
Just like the arc of the rainbow that reassures us in the hope of an end to a storm — it helps us see the forest for the trees. All we have to do is open our eyes.
Please share your thoughts: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
