After bringing up the subject of religion and politics, I probably won’t get many invitations to this year’s Thanksgiving gathering of family and friends. While I’m not the least bit interested in seeing turkey legs weaponized at the holiday dinner table, I do wonder why these two things are so hard to talk about in polite settings.

These two mainstays of modern life are thought to be too private and too contentious to be included in conversations over a quiet meal. However, both religion and politics play a crucial role in many of our individual lives and certainly in America’s increasingly polarized public square. Besides, I’m someone foolish enough (according to many readers) to take on a touchy topic.

Religious views have been a source of comfort and meaning for many throughout human history. Faith from a spiritual worldview provides a basis for moral beliefs and behaviors. It also can provide a sense of community and connection to tradition.

Politics of various sorts are essential to educate a country’s citizens on how to form a governing body. In a representative democracy where we don’t directly rule ourselves, politics helps us to determine the qualities of those who makes our laws and how public resources are allocated.

Our internal beliefs, along with our external politics, are like the mind and body relationship. When both our “religion” and our “politics” enjoy healthy checks and balances, the “pursuit of happiness” seems far more plausible.

America’s founders, given their previous experiences in Europe, thankfully were clear about the separation of “church and state,” by adding the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. They also were mindful of how important moral values were to the success of the democratic republic they were forming. As the country’s fourth president James Madison cautioned, “If individuals be not influenced by moral principles, it is in vain to look for public virtue …”

With private and public virtue increasingly in short supply, it seems Madison’s warning is sadly coming true. Whether there is a correlation with the rash of recent scandalous behavior of both religious and political figures, it’s evident that Americans are abandoning their traditional places of worship and their established political parties faster than Washoe Lake evaporates every year.

For instance, U.S. church membership was 73% when Gallup began measuring it in 1937, and it held steady around 70% for the rest of the century. But America’s membership in houses of worship dropped below 50% in 2020 for the first time in Gallup’s eight-decade trend — 47% of Americans said they belonged to a church, synagogue or mosque, down from 50% in 2018 and 70% in 1999.

The same trend can be seen in the dwindling voter registration numbers of both political parties. Gallup Polling last month found that “a record 49% of Americans see themselves as politically independent — the same as the two major parties put together,” Axios reported in April.

According to D.C. publication The Hill, “Nonpartisan voters now make up Nevada’s largest group of registered voters, according to new data from its secretary of state. The more than 605,000 registered nonpartisans edge out the almost 602,000 registered Democrats in the state, as well as 551,000 registered Republicans. That’s roughly 74,000 more nonpartisan voters than Nevada had before the midterm elections. At this point in 2019, just more than 346,000 voters in the state were nonpartisan.”

To quote the Buffalo Springfield’s ’60s anthem “For What It’s Worth,” “There’s something happening here … what it is ain’t exactly clear.” Maybe so, but what is taking place is traditional gathering places like churches and political parties are in gradual decline. The question is why?

Having been a nun and a former Washoe County commissioner, Rene Reid has a unique perspective.

“I see people leaving both religion and politics overall as a positive sign,” she told me. “People are no longer willing to just be part of the crowd but are searching for their own path to follow. In politics, many are unhappy with the bickering on both sides with little ability to find common ground. In religion, in particular the Catholic Church, people are fed up with the clergy sex abuse scandal and searching for a way to live a more meaningful life.”

Local attorney Jason Guinasso has been a political candidate and is also a pastor. Guinasso, like Reid, doesn’t see the trend of moving away from traditional affiliations as necessarily a bad thing: “There certainly is an individual expression of faith that is causing people to rethink what religion is for them. People are finding other ways to engage their faith authentically in things like the smaller home church movement across the country.”

Speaking of the growing distaste for both institutionalized religion and politics, Guinasso says, “There’s been a growing thread of basic distrust of political and religious institutions over the last 20 years, because they have failed us in one way or another.”

All of this may not be the end of the world, but it does signal some changes in the way our present world operates. In my view, the fact that faith has become more personal and less formalized is a good thing. Whether it be podcasts that have replaced preachers, or small study groups that have supplanted parishes, it’s apparent that our search for what’s important in life has evolved, as have the growing number of tools at our disposal to discover all the clues left behind in the universe by the Creator.

Coincidently, Nevada voters no longer need to stand on political-activist-generated platforms and vote as party bosses decree. Nonpartisans are now a majority and one day soon may make bipartisanship in vogue again. Individuals of conscience have decentralized the political process. Maybe they will eventually elect more statesman- and stateswoman-like individuals with a less polarizing approach to the policy process itself.

We have a long way to go to build bridges over the barriers that have separated us. Maybe then, we can follow the advice of Thomas Jefferson: “I never considered a difference of opinion in politics, in religion, in philosophy, as cause for withdrawing from a friend.”

If we end up losing some parts of our old religious and political traditions by replacing them with better ways of connecting both the sacred and the secular, maybe then, we can talk about anything in the world we want to at the next Thanksgiving dinner together.

Thank you for your faithful feedback at: pathickey@dataclonemail.com

“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.