Nevada can fix our problem and rebuild public trust — even against the odds.
Nevada … we have a problem.
Just like Apollo 13 — when mission commander Jim Lovell (or Tom Hanks if you prefer) called NASA to report an explosion onboard the manned spacecraft before uttering the now famous line: “Houston, we have a problem” —Nevada’s unforeseen situation is that a political implosion of sorts has occurred on our own ship of state. Like NASA, we’ve missed a number of warning signs that has led to the rise of voter discontent with the election process.
The problem was recently diagnosed by a new poll from the Associated Press that found “only about 1 in 10 U.S. adults give high ratings to the way democracy works in the United States or how well it represents the interests of most Americans.”
Trust is key to the integrity of our election process. As one RGJ reader and retired journalism professor said in an email to me, “Election integrity means votes are counted by nonpartisan mechanisms and promptly certified by the appropriate state officials. And, it means that all citizens of the state respect the results.”
First, let me be clear about what I’m about to say. I don’t agree with President Trump and the “Stop the Steal” zealots regarding the 2020 presidential election. Their mostly unfounded claims are full of hyperbole, exaggeration and fearmongering. I agree with Republican secretary of state at the time, Barbara Cegavske, who said, “Unfortunately, members of my own party continue to believe the 2020 general election was wrought with fraud — despite a complete lack of evidence to support that belief.”
Demagoguery aside, to suggest elections aren’t susceptible to problems — or at times even fraud — is either to ignore our own history, or just be plain naïve. Look nationally at the numerous instances of mail fraud, driver’s license fraud, health care fraud, debit and credit card fraud, bank account takeover fraud, stolen tax refund fraud, COVID-era fraud, Internet fraud — just to name a few. Trickery and the bending of rules in politics exists about as abundantly as cheatgrass on Western Nevada’s foothills. To suggest that politically motivated individuals or groups of every conceivable type are immune from election shenanigans and outright crimes is to place humanity on a pedestal that even a mostly positive guy like myself can’t quite accept.
The two issues that constantly get stuck in voter’s craw are laws governing voter IDs and mail-in voting. On the subject of voter identification, a recent Monmouth University poll found that “an overwhelming majority (81%) of respondents say they support voters being required to show ID in order to vote, including 62% of Democrats.” Former President Jimmy Carter of Georgia, which has voter ID, said on the issue, “It’s disgraceful and embarrassing … Americans have to remember you have to have the equivalent to what we’re requiring to cast a ballot to cash a check or board a plane.”
Thirty-six other states require or request voters to present identification at the polls. Democrats in Carson City have blocked attempts requiring any form of ID at polling places in Nevada. Proponents argue that everyone who favors voter ID is either a racist or is attempting to suppress voter turnout, as I’m sure I will be now be accused of since I’ve written this. However, such hyperbole from the left this time flies in the face of an NAACP study that found “the 2020 presidential election broke records for voter turnout, including the number of minorities that cast a ballot.” For critics who suggest that minority voters are routinely prevented from getting IDs is hardly ever the case; and besides, it’s patronizing and condescending to those voters.
Nevada, like some other states, used the excuse of pandemic-stye practices (mail-in voting) to fundamentally change the rules of its elections. These changes, which were reasonable during the pandemic, have become the new norm. Even so, mail-in voting was anything but a success in the Silver State. According to a survey by the U.S. Election Assistance Commission, “Among eight states with universal vote-by-mail elections in 2022, Nevada ranked last in ballots cast by mail. Nevada also recorded the lowest rate of any state for percentage of mail ballots returned.”
If mail-in votes and the companion practice of ballot harvesting that is now allowed under Nevada law are to become the new normal as Democrats seemingly prefer, then Nevada should pursue every reasonable precaution because signature verification systems are anything but failsafe.
Given these two contentious issues, which have caused an erosion of trust in elections for many Nevadans, what can be done? Efforts to insure safeguards must begin with Nevada’s chief elections officer, the secretary of state. Some states have made the secretary of state a nonpartisan position out of the fear that an overly partisan individual might tip the scale in elections for their own political party.
Nevada’s current secretary of state, Cisco Aguilar, was elected with broad bipartisan support, including mine. As such, former Nevada GOP chairwoman Amy Tarkanian, who also endorsed Cisco while still being concerned about “mail-in ballots and ballot harvesting,” is pleased to have been appointed by the Democrat to an advisory committee on elections. I believe he will listen to feedback from those on the other side of the aisle.
Whether members of both old political parties will stop their polarizing partisanship to truly represent the majority of Nevadans (nonpartisans are about to overtake R’s and D’s), remains to be seen. Some, like a retired Nevada judge who emailed me have gone so far as to suggest that Nevada voters should consider voting for open primaries: “Open primaries are one way to drive candidates to the middle, rather than the edges of policy positions, and could possibly attract more mainstream candidates.”
Rebuilding trust in the political process starts with the people who run for office. How they behave after they are elected is the key to restoring the public’s trust in our representative democracy.
The Apollo 13 space mission was designated a “successful failure” because the crew returned home safely even though the odds were stacked against them.
I welcome your continued feedback at: pathickey@dataclonemail.com, even if you wouldn’t vote for me in a million years.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
