Many parents thought that personal cellphones would help their children to become smarter and feel safer in school. But according to a growing number of studies, “smartphones” in the classroom appear to be a dumb policy when it comes to both learning environments and the mental well-being of students themselves.

As concerns have grown about adolescents’ worsening mental health, much of the discussion has centered on teens’ constant use of their phones and social media. U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy earlier this year said kids younger than 14 shouldn’t use social media, and he later issued a public health advisory highlighting social media’s potential harms to young people’s mental health.

A growing number of studies have linked children’s use of smartphones and social media to their deteriorating mental health. For instance, a 2023 systematic review of 50 research articles published in the journal BMC Psychology revealed that screen time was correlated with problems in teens’ mental well-being, and that social media use was tied to an increased risk of depression.

It’s estimated that American high school students spend an average of 7-9 hours a day on their phones, while time with friends has gone down 65% since 2010. It’s as if relation-based childhoods have been replaced by phone-based ones.

I’ve seen it firsthand. While I was a member of the State Board of Education, I volunteered as a substitute teacher in the Washoe County School District. I witnessed how prevalent — and in fact distracting — cellphones are to both students and teachers in our classrooms. It’s why while visiting Atlanta recently, I took advantage of an opportunity to attend a “National Summit on Education” sponsored by ExcelinEd (excelined.org) where the featured speaker was renowned American social psychologist Jonathan Haidt.

Haidt’s research on the current mental health crisis of Gen Z (youth born between 1997-2012), is being widely debated in editorial pages like the Washington Post: “Schools should ban smartphones. Parents should help.” Haidt’s recent Atlantic Monthly article “Get Phones Out of Schools Now” has spurred a national debate from state houses, to school board meetings, to discussions around the kitchen table. The crux of his data-based arguments are that unrestricted cellphone use by children impedes learning, stunts relationships and lessons a sense of belonging in teens.

Cellphone use among teenagers has in fact become a kind of addiction.

“Smartphones are basically kryptonite for learning,” Haidt said. “When children have a phone in their pocket, and most schools say you have to keep your phone in your pocket, you can’t use it during class, is like saying in a drug detox clinic, ‘You can keep your heroin in your pocket, just don’t shoot up.'”

Research shows that cellphones have become a major distraction in the classroom. Teachers complain that too many students are off-task and not paying attention. To many classroom teachers, dealing with the problem is a constant battle throughout the day, and it’s becoming exhausting.

Local teachers like Mario Fitzpatrick agree. Mario has been teaching for 18 years and is currently a social studies instructor at McQueen High School in Reno.

“Cellphones are really interfering with students ability to learn in the classroom,” he says. “Students are constantly thinking about what’s going on in their cellphones and not what’s going on in class.”

And there is a lot that’s going on in kids’ cellphones that are both distracting and disturbing. Students are being inundated by social media notifications. A recent report from Common Sense Media, which tracked about 200 young people with Android phones, found that participants typically received 237 cellphone notifications during the day — about one quarter of them during school hours. In 2021, 16 percent of U.S. high school students said they had been bullied via text message or social media platforms like Instagram over the previous year, according to a report this year from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

A growing response to what some have called an “epidemic” worse than COVID has been to ban cellphone use in the classroom. In early October, the British government issued new guidelines recommending that student cellphone use be prohibited in schools nationwide. That followed Italy, which last year banned cellphones during lessons, and China, which two years ago barred children from taking phones to school. Earlier this year, Florida passed a law requiring public schools to ban student cellphone use during class time.

For those that argue that such bans on children’s “screen time” during class time is an infringement on their freedom, McQueen teacher Mario Fitzpatrick says that students frequently feel that they are either being recorded or photographed by their fellow students — and it’s had a chilling effect upon their willingness to participate in class discussions. Teachers like Mario, who enforces a strict cellphone ban in his classroom, believes a cellphone-free environment will lead to less incidents of cyberbullying, improve attendance and reduce time on social media (and associated mental health problems). The most often-cited reason is to improve engagement in class.

Mario does see a problem with the “unequal enforcement” of classroom cellphone policies and wishes WCSD would come up with a districtwide approach. Currently, the school district’s policy is vague and inconsistent. While stating the policy is “intended to limit the possibility of personal electronic devices interfering with classroom instruction and student learning … We will continually remind students to engage in class by taking off their earbuds, turning off their phones/ devices and placing them in their backpacks.” Which means teachers are left with decisions on how to enforce (or not) — and the reason why so many are troubled and fatigued over the matter.

Angela Orr is a former WCSD official who now is the Principal of Doral Academy charter school. She instituted a phone-free policy for her entire K-8 school and says teachers and parents are on board with the decision. At recess she says, “Our kids really play — they are not on their phones.”

As reported recently by CBS News, Newburgh Free Academy in New York stands as a testament to the growing trend. Students at the public high school begin their day by putting their phones in pouches, which remain locked for seven hours, including at lunchtime. “It’s a game-changer; it’s night and day. I saw kids’ faces again,” said Dennis Maher, an English teacher.

While it will be heavy lift for WCSD to lead the discussion for a policy change with real teeth, not to do so will only further stunt children’s academic and social-emotional growth. Officials within Nevada’s education establishment must be willing not only to do something of critical importance to students, but also to face down the unavoidable pushback. The pushback will come from students, of course, but also from parents who like the convenience and false sense of security afforded by equipping their children with phones.

Not to get smartphones under control in the classroom is about the dumbest thing we can do.

Email me on your cellphone, as long as you are not in class: tahoeboy68 @gmail.com.

“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.