Evolution or revolution? Nevada’s governor thinks a bit of both is best.
Joe Lombardo recently appointed two high-performing public charter school leaders to key state education posts. In selecting the two women who have been successful school principals in 5-star-rated Nevada charter schools, the governor said, “Charter schools are a critical part of our education infrastructure. Ensuring people are in leadership positions who understand the value of charter options is a priority of my administration.”
Former Arizona lawmaker Eddy Ableser, who serves on Doral Academy’s Foundation board says; “Governor Lombardo has chosen two highly effective education leaders that have created quality schools in Nevada and education for their students.”
Angela Orr, principal of Doral Academy off the Mt. Rose Highway, was appointed to serve on the State Board of Education for District 2, which includes all of Reno and Sparks and most of rural Northern Nevada. Before becoming principal at Doral, Orr served for years in the Washoe County School District, as both as a classroom social studies teacher and professional learning specialist who has worked with UNR’s School of Education in preparing new teachers for the classroom.
“I’m passionate about making sure that all public schools, which include public charter schools, are funded adequately, that those things are fair, that are coming from the state,” Orr says. “But more importantly, I’m much more concerned that our state spends as much time thinking about literacy as it does other things in education. Because for me, my greatest passion is literacy, the science of reading.”
Orr’s passion for reading has resulted in students at both the elementary and middle school level at Doral scoring 73 percent in proficiency in both reading and math.
The other governor appointee is Melissa Mackedon, a native Nevadan from Fallon, to serve as the executive director of the State Public Charter School Authority, which administers and holds accountable state-sponsored charter schools in Nevada. A former teacher from Churchill County, Mackedon founded Oasis Academy, a K-12 public charter school in 2011. Oasis is a Nevada governor-designated STEM school (science, technology, engineering and math) that has graduated 100% of its high school students while maintaining a 5-star rating during its existence.
Mackedon says having lead a successful public charter school will help in her new role: “I think it obviously gives a new lens to see the work through, and I think it’s a lens that’s only going to help the charter authority. Having someone who’s founded a school and then run that school successfully for multiple years is a perspective we haven’t ever had before.”
There are few, if any, documented instances of troubled schools being turned around without the intervention by a powerful leader. Research confirms that if a school is fortunate to have a great principal, students and teachers alike have a far better chance of academic progress. Professor Michael Fullan, writing in the Teachers College Press, says, “I know of no improving school that that doesn’t have a principal who is good at leading improvement.” Stanford University’s recent study entitled “School Leaders Matter: Measuring the Impact of Effective Principals” concluded the same.
By appointing two highly effective school leaders to key state education jobs, the governor is hoping to begin a change in how Nevada performs in K-12 classrooms. But will it be enough to move the needle?
I would argue that more than mere reforms — which are a kind of an evolution — we need more a revolution in education. The New York Times’ David Brooks agrees. He recently wrote a piece entitled “America Should be in the Middle of a School Revolution,” in which he noted there is “a complete absence of (educational) leadership” nationally.
Despite spending more money than most nations in the developed world on education, the U.S. has fallen behind many of its counterparts in Europe and Asia. Some say it’s time to do more than just tinker with a broken system.
Arnie Duncan was President Barack Obama’s secretary of education from 2009 through 2015. Speaking about the U.S. education system, he said, “It’s obvious the system is broken. Let’s admit it’s broken, let’s admit it’s dysfunctional, and let’s do something dramatically different, and let’s do it now. Don’t just tinker about the edges. Let’s fix the thing.”
Something that’s obviously easier said than done — especially when you are talking about either fixing, reforming, or revolutionizing a governmental institution. As Stanford’s Terry Moe has written in his book, “The Politics of Institutional Reform,” he points out that “all governmental institutions across all areas of public policy naturally and inevitably generate vested interests, and these vested interests use their power in the political process to protect their institutions from change.”
Some of those vested interests have pushed back against public charter schools — especially teachers’ unions. Because most charter schools don’t unionize, they have attracted the ire of organized labor and their supporters in public education. Still, new charter school leaders like Angela Orr prefer a spirit of cooperation with traditional school districts — not competition and consternation. Orr, who has taught in a local district schools, says, “I’m proud of the fact that I still work closely with my colleagues in WCSD. We share ideas, we share professional learning. We discuss ways to make education better for students.”
Orr also understands how her new role as a member of the State Board of Education will help her be “an advocate for just helping people to better understand what public charter schools are, that there is indeed a grand bargain that in order for a little bit more autonomy in decision-making, but there’s also much more increased accountability. And that is probably why so many state charters are in the top 10 and top 20 schools in our state because of that level of accountability.”
America’s current education system became compulsory following the 18th-century Industrial Revolution, where workers were needed for the economic development demands of the time.
Today’s multifaceted economy requires students to be diverse, curious and creative. Individualized and personalized learning is necessary for most to succeed in a world that’s constantly changing. Transforming how we educate our young is going to have change as well. Command and control systems from centralized bureaucracies are increasingly ineffective. Disruptive innovations like micro-schools, tuition-free public charters and affordable private schools are all playing a role in diversifying education and making for better student outcomes.
Still, it won’t be easy. As Abraham Lincoln said during the tumultuous times he governed: “The dogmas of the quiet past are inadequate to the stormy present.”
Governor Lombardo is wise to recognize this fact as well, when it comes to Nevada’s education system. And so should we embrace change.
Please email me your thoughts at: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016. Hickey also served on the State Board of Education from 2016 to 2017, and served as executive director of the Charter School Association of Nevada.
