We’ve been down this road before on immigration. Ever since the inception of America, we’ve been a country made up of immigrants dreaming of a better life. Even our Native Americans, apparently came here from elsewhere.
My own ancestors fled the potato famine and the depressing economic conditions of Ireland in the mid-1800s, coming first through Ellis Island in New York, and then across the U.S. by rail before eventually settling in Nevada and Montana.
Immigration is part of our blood and is an integral part of our heritage as Americans. As poet Robert Frost wrote in “The Road Not Taken,” the pathways our previous relatives took have “made all the difference” to what this country has become.
A pause is required while we define ourselves
The problem today is that mass immigration is a roadway overpopulated with too little controls. A Wall Street Journal national poll conducted in late February found that 20% of voters now rank immigration as their top issue, up from 13% in December.
Even a progressive presidential candidate like Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is calling for America to close its borders until the migrant crisis can brought under control and new immigration policies are re-thought.
America is no longer a young nation needing millions of people to occupy its vast lands and emerging economies throughout a growing continent’s new cities. Many of our cities are hard-pressed to welcome new arrivals. Socially and politically, we are more like an adolescent country, awkwardly trying to define our identity in a ever-changing and uncertain world.
A pause is required while we decide what America 2.0 should be.
Even so, any new immigration policies (and they are desperately needed) should be in keeping with what many feel is our national heritage. The 1883 poem written by American Emma Lazarus etched in bronze and mounted on the Statue of Liberty’s pedestal has again been catapulted into a heated political debate on immigration: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free …”
‘Incredibly grateful to start at new life’
Looking for inspiration while writing this column, I attended the Northern Nevada International Center’s 25th Anniversary Gala at the Grand Sierra Resort. The NNIC is the only refugee resettlement agency in the United States that has a formal relationship with an institute of higher education: the University of Nevada, Reno. President Brian Sandoval was the event’s keynote speaker.
Heart-moving scenes were in abundance that evening, as were the multiethnic foods and dress of the many refugee families who were there to give thanks for the kindness and support of the many Nevadans who have assisted in helping them to become new Americans.
Most of the recent refugees granted asylum in Reno have come from three of the many war-torn countries in our world: Afghanistan, Syria and Ukraine.
“The legally vetted refugees are incredibly grateful to start a new life in this country,” NNIC Board President Alison Gaulden told me. “They did not come here looking for a handout. With NNIC’s assistance, most lead sustainable lives within six months of coming here.”
Speaking with a 12-year old boy from Afghanistan who came to Reno as a result of NNIC’s refugee resettlement program, I couldn’t help but feel a sense of relief that had least one family who had supported the United States’ efforts against the barbaric Taliban was rewarded with an opportunity for freedom in America.
Of course, thousands of real political refugees who are coming here legally are not the same as the millions of immigrants who are entering the United States illegally, mostly across the Southern border.
‘Human tsunami’
Illegal immigration in the U.S. has become “a human tsunami of previously unfathomable size,” writes Todd Bensman, a senior national security fellow at the Center for Immigration Studies.
“Entering 2024, border apprehensions were up to 12,000 to 15,000 per day,” Bensman adds. “The reality is even worse, because these numbers do not include the people who entered the U.S. illegally without being apprehended — sometimes referred to as ‘gotaways’ — a number the Border Patrol estimates but does not make public. That estimate over the past three years is 2 million, bringing the three-year total of illegal immigrants to 10 million — a number equivalent to the population of Greater London or Greater Chicago.”
It’s too early to gauge the full impact of the ongoing settlement of millions of illegal foreign nationals in the U.S., but it’s extremely costly. There is the burden placed on public school districts that have no choice but to take in millions of new children who often don’t speak English and whose educations are not commensurate with those of their schoolmates. It is probably not coincidental that hospital systems across the nation have fallen deep into the red since the great mass migration crisis began. And large cities across the country are looking to Washington for help with unfunded and unexpected fiscal burdens reaching into the tens of billions to care for the hundreds of thousands showing up with hands out.
Another problem, as the New York Times recently reported: “Migrant smuggling on the U.S. Southern border has evolved in the past 10 years from scattered network of freelance ‘coyotes’ into a multimillion-dollar international business controlled by organized crime, including some of Mexico’s most violent drug cartels.”
As a compassionate nation of immigrant descendants ourselves, the American electorate is losing patience with the out-of-control situation at the Southern border. The very definition of a nation itself requires a secure border. As the 2024 presidential campaign heats up, American attitudes toward migrants and migration are turning more negative.
The next president and Congress surely must develop and enforce a secure and sustainable system of immigration laws. A new legal immigration system needs to be fashioned to respond more accurately to labor market needs, and enhance U.S. competitiveness. We need to restore the integrity of immigration laws that discourages employers and employees from operating outside the legal system. We will also need to find a fair, humane and orderly way to allow many of millions of migrants currently living in the United States to earn the right to remain legally.
We can’t let flame be extinguished
America is a proud nation built by immigrants. If we are to continue to be a light in an increasingly dark world, we have to insure that our capacity to be that “Lady Liberty” isn’t extinguished by our own clumsy attempts at inclusiveness.
Compared to most countries, America has chosen the frequently traveled road of steady migrations. Now is the time, as the poet Robert Frost found out … that it’s sometimes better to take the road “less traveled by.”
Deciding who, and how, future Americans migrate to this country is something that is best for the nation’s well-being, and is also for best for those who become the next generations of new Americans.
Please email me your thoughts: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
