The media has been called a lot of things lately. Most aren’t nice. The media and the press are frequently referred to in a derogatory sense as a kind of dog, be it a watchdog, lapdog, attack dog or even a guide dog.
While dogs may still be our best of friends, dogs are also capable of demonstrating a lack of restraint, a lack of hospitality, a lack of loyalty — and at times, a fair amount of indiscriminate and excessive viciousness.
The question then becomes: Has today’s media (especially social media) torn itself off from any ethical leash?
The erosion of public trust in media is noted by the Pew Research Center’s 2013 study “Critical Ratings of News Organizations’ Core Functions.”
“Though the public gives news organizations credit for their role as watchdogs, they offer much more negative ratings of other aspects central to the press’s core mission,” the study’s author wrote. “Overwhelming majorities express doubts about news organizations’ independence: 76% say news organizations tend to favor one side and 75% say that they are often influenced by powerful people and organizations.”
The very foundation of America’s form of democracy was contingent upon a free and responsible press. The U.S. Constitution makes very clear that freedom of the press should not be infringed. A cornerstone of our society is the open market of information which can be shared through ever expanding mediums. The media serves as a conduit of information between our governments and communities across the country.
In a 1787 letter, the Declaration of Independence’s main author, Thomas Jefferson, made it clear how important the press (or in today’s term, media) is: “Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.”
Modern journalists have echoed the third U.S. president’s notion. Media legend Bill Moyers was a key player in the creation of the public broadcasting system in America. “Without a free and independent press, this 250-year-old experiment in self-government will not make it,” he said in his keynote address to the National Media Reform Conference in 2008. “As journalism goes, so goes democracy.”
Both democracy and journalism appear to be on fleeting ground.
The press in the U.S. has been afforded a private invitation to the inner sanctum of America’s public square, with some even calling media a member of the “fourth estate.” The reference to a seat at the table with the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government was because of the belief that the “checks and balances” envisioned by the founders would be best preserved by a free and discerning coverage of the news.
But therein lies the problem. The content of the news media typically reflects the interests of those who finance the news outlet. News agencies in general are agencies of someone’s power. All institutions naturally and inevitably generate vested interests, and these vested interests use their influence over the process to protect those who share their political values.
The problem for many conservatives in America today is the perceived dominance of a liberal bias in many major media entities. According to a 2022 Pew Research Center study, “A little more than half of the journalists surveyed (55%) say that every side does not always deserve equal coverage in the news. By contrast, 22% of Americans overall say the same, whereas about three-quarters (76%) say journalists should always strive to give all sides equal coverage.”
A 2006 article in UCLA College Report, “Media Bias: It’s Real, but Surprising,” reinforced the claim of many conservatives.
“I suspected that many media outlets would tilt to the left because surveys have shown that reporters tend to vote more Democrat than Republican,” UCLA political science researcher Tim Groseclose said. “But, I was surprised at just how pronounced the distinctions are.”
Even liberals like Uri Berliner, a senior National Public Broadcast business editor who recently resigned from NPR after 25 years, wrote for the Free Press, “NPR has lost America’s trust by approaching news stories with a progressive frame of mind.”
Regardless of whether it’s a “liberal” or “conservative” source that most Americans get their news from, the end result is the divisive trend of political polarization. New York Times columnist Ezra Klein, in his book “Why We’re Polarized,” decries the divisions that media is contributing to: “Step back and look at how a political media system increasingly deepens political identity, hardens polarization, and raises the political stakes.”
Conservative author and radio talk show host Charles Sykes, has similar comments about his friends on the right: “Conservative activists advanced an alternative way of knowing the world, that was embodied in their notion of ‘liberal media bias.'”
Some, though, would say Sykes isn’t all that wrong. According to Pulitzer Prize winning playwright David Mamet (“The Verdict” and “The Untouchables”), “The Left blacklists, cancels, and indicts contrary opinion — not in opposition to dissent, but to dissuade from mutiny.”
Personally, I believe the media must play a key role as a watchdog over our government and our elected officials. I benefited myself while serving in elected office from the press pointing out how at times I needed to be more transparent. A watchful guardian, especially against illegal or unethical conduct, is a prerequisite for any representative democracy to succeed. Problems arise though when “watchdogs” become “guard dogs,” behaving like sentries for one dominant political or media institution over another.
I support the media’s role as a watchdog, as long as it stays tethered to an ethical leash. It’s why I chose to call my column “Memo from the Middle.” While I may at times succumb to my own political biases, I try to remember that Nevadans have many different viewpoints. I write my weekly piece trying to be a “guide dog,” with a hoped-for blind allegiance to principle, but not to any particular political party or persuasion.
As an opinion writer, I try with my columns not to tell my readers what to think, but instead, what to think about. Besides, I’d rather be a seeing-eye dog than just another barking political animal.
Thank you. Email me your thoughts at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
