It started with political correctness. It’s evolved into terms like “woke” and “cancel culture.” What began as a reaction to speech or actions that were deemed unacceptable by some has turned into the practice of publicly shaming or silencing people with objectionable political views or lives.
The problem civil libertarians have with silencing or “canceling” others’ personal or political views is that it flies in the face of the First Amendment. It’s the equivalent to mandating a social mask to cover what comes out of the mouths of your fellow Americans.
It’s as if freedom “of” speech has become freedom “from” speech, for many of those who worship at the holier-than-thou shrines of wokeness and cancel culture. The whole thing reminds me of how I felt in the late ’60s in college when I first read George Orwell’s “Nineteen Eighty-Four.” The dystopian novel described the tactics of the “Thought Police,” who were responsible for discovering and punishing the unacceptable thoughts of those opposed to the status quo.
Reno’s Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Warren Lerude taught “The First Amendment and Society” at UNR for 28 years. Lerude believes, “The terms ‘wokeness’ and ‘cancel culture’ are passing fads. It’s all gobbledygook. Most people don’t know what they mean, including many who persist in using them.”
What are some examples of cancel culture gone mad, you ask? Removed on public platforms like TV, Twitter and the NFL, figures canceled by the Left were the likes of J.K. Rowling, Donald Trump and Joe Rogan. Those who have been canceled by the right include Colin Kaepernick, Ellen DeGeneres and the Dixie Chicks.
Not exactly wearing flowers in their hair, or professing peace and love — it took the San Francisco School Board just five seconds to remove Abraham Lincoln’s name from one of its longstanding high schools. George Washington took 12 seconds. In a 6-1 vote, board members removed the names of former presidents and other suspect individuals like John Muir, Robert Louis Stevenson and even San Francisco’s own Senator Diane Feinstein from over one-third of the city’s schools. It was determined that these disgraced historical figures were “guilty of being variously, colonizers; slave owners; exploiters of workers; oppressors of women, children, or queer and transgender people; people connected to human rights or environmental abuses; and espousers of racist beliefs.”
Under such a politically expedient ideology, the past cannot be understood on its own terms, but must be judged through the morals and mores of the present. In retrospect, three of the six school commissioners were subsequently ousted in a landslide election by a local liberal electorate who were not pleased about erasing history in such an illiberal fashion.
Conformity to current societal norms makes it tough on historical figures and for contemporary figures who question in-vogue political morality. Comedians like Bill Maher and Dave Chappelle have gotten themselves into hot water for making light of the hypocrisy of those sitting in judgment over others. Then again, fanatics — whether they be religious fundamentalists or woke warriors — usually come up short in the sense-of-humor department.
However, it’s not exactly funny to have to give up a coveted position like being a columnist for the New York Times because you refuse to be “edited” by the digital version of the Thought Police on Twitter who routinely scan social media accounts for “problematic” content. Bari Weiss was a columnist with the NYT, but resigned because: “Twitter is not on the masthead of The New York Times. Twitter has become its ultimate editor. As the ethics and mores of that platform have become those of the paper, the paper itself has increasingly become a kind of performance space.”
Writing further in “Commentary” about wokeness and cancel culture, Weiss, now a successful podcaster, explains: “Persuasion is replaced with public shaming. Moral complexity is replaced with moral certainty. Facts are replaced with feelings. Ideas are replaced with identity. Forgiveness is replaced with punishment. Diversity is replaced with homogeneity of thought. Inclusion, with exclusion.” Wow.
I’m old enough to remember the time when the diversity of thought (and even non-violent actions) were defended by liberals. The ACLU once famously defended the rights of Neo-Nazis to march through the streets of Skokie, Illinois, and the Klux Klux Klan, to do the same in the South. The iconic civil rights organization has now refused to take such First Amendment stands. David Goldberger, a Jewish law professor who was the once the legal director for the Illinois ACLU, defended the free speech of those whose views he found repugnant.
“I got the sense it was more important for ACLU staff to identify with clients and progressive causes than to stand on principle,” he said in a recent interview. “Liberals are leaving the First Amendment behind.”
One reason that the formation of the United States was exceptional was in its first-in-history ideal of each person being free to pursue their own version of life, liberty and happiness. Nowhere is that uniqueness more embodied than in our human qualities of thought and speech. Our advanced abilities to think, learn and communicate makes humanity genuinely different from all other creatures on this planet.
Which is why how we view others thoughts and words are worthy of respect, even when we vehemently disagree. The bastion of liberalism, the New York Times, recently editorialized that “America has a Free Speech Problem,” saying; “For all the tolerance and enlightenment that modern society claims, Americans are losing hold of a fundamental right as citizens of a free country: the right to speak their minds and voice their opinions in public without fear of being shamed or shunned.”
The social silencing of America has contributed to the state of our current hyperpartisanship and polarizing politics. However you define cancel culture, Americans know it exists and are growing tired of its bothersome presence. In a poll by Times Opinion and Siena College, 84 percent of adults said it’ “very serious” or “somewhat serious” that Americans can’t share their opinions “without fear of retaliation, censorship or punishment.”
Nevadans just finished celebrating the diverse elements in our population that make the Black Rock Desert home to Burning Man every year. Why not equally acknowledge those who join in the spectacle of NASCAR Races at the Las Vegas Motor Speedway? Both have different lifestyles. Both have different worldviews. Both events freely happen in America.
“Different strokes for different folks,” including what they think and say, are what makes America great. Why put a muzzle on freedom of thought or expression?
It’s time to take our masks off.
Agree or not, contact me at: pathickey@dataclonemail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
