When I first pitched the idea to the editors of the RGJ for writing a column entitled “Memo from the Middle,” I had a faint idea of how the growing divisions in America were harming us as a people and a nation.
Four and a half years later, I think we all see more clearly how dangerously divided we’ve become, and how much a threat the current state of politics is posing to our very existence as a free and democratic country.
Writing this column during the dark days of COVID-19, I found that Nevadans preferred stories of reassurance and comfort over dire warnings and lockdowns. Family, friends, and sometimes faith — along with the necessary medical vaccines and precautions — were what got most people through the pandemic.
Even though I personally served in elected office (and am grateful for the opportunity to have done so), I take little pleasure in writing about the state of politics these days. It’s why you see me wandering off the political trail to write about hikes around my boyhood home of Lake Tahoe, or about an unsung local school bus driver who loved and gained the respect of his fellow drivers, regardless of whether they were “MAGA” or “woke.” Or, writing about a German scientist who took me somewhere in nowhere Nevada to learn about our natural past. These are the things that reassure me that life is good, as are the Nevadans that comprise it. Today’s politics and politicians are doing their damnedest to convince me otherwise.
As regular readers of this column know, I end my opinion pieces with an invitation for readers to share their thoughts about what I’ve written; for or against. One of the most common criticisms I receive is for not taking a stand on either Biden or Trump — or now, Trump vs Harris. Let me explain.
As the old adage goes, “where you stand on an issue is where you sit politically.” My problem, like a majority of Nevadans, is that I’m politically homeless. So, too, are a majority of Nevadans according to the Secretary of State’s latest voter registration numbers: 40% nonpartisan or small-party affiliation, 30% Democrat, 29% Republican. It’s not that I feel victimized, or any less happy about not having a political organization to call home; I feel much freer being an independent.
My reasons for leaving the Republican Party are much the same as the explanation I hear many Democrats give for having left their traditional political home: They feel the party left them.
Still, as many of my friends and critics alike both say, I have to pick a side; or at least pick a candidate who is the “lesser of two evils.” At that point in the conversation, I’m usually provided a litany of candidates’ “evils” in sordid detail.
Personally, I prefer to vote “for” someone, and not merely “against” a candidate. Following are some of my issues with each of the two current presidential candidates.
Donald Trump: I have a problem with both his personality and his character. Questionable ethics in his long history of business dealings, and his equally sketchy moral commitments in his numerous marriages, serve as a red flag to me. The fact that so many of the individuals that served with him during his first administration, including a vice president who was loyal to the very end (until loyalty meant violating the U.S. Constitution) are not in support of him. That fact alone says something important to me.
While character can be instilled while in politics, it can also be revealed. Trump’s insistence that other word leaders “fear” him is not enough to reassure me about his leadership, given how unwilling he seems to accept advice from anyone other those who agree with his views. While Trump’s policies in his first term were preferable to Joe Biden’s (economically and in the Middle East), his strident overconfidence and exaggeration, as exemplified in his campaign rallies, have become blustery and cliché without being compelling to me.
If you make enemies of your opponents, as Trump has famously done with his bombastic rhetoric, how can he expect them to work with him once he’s reelected? They won’t. Being honest, as a former Republican, I supported many of his policies. As an American, I seriously worry about Donald Trump’s ability to be effective at the presidential helm for another term.
Kamala Harris: She is an interesting person and a well-scripted candidate. What troubles me most about her is that her dress rehearsal for the highest office in the land has been done primarily through Democratic Party appointments and without her positions as a presidential candidate being scrutinized by either primary voters or an inquisitive press. While her debate skills and media savvy were on full display in her one presidential debate with former President Trump, she escaped being challenged or fact-checked by ABC’s friendly moderators during the 90-minute debate. While she was asked about some of the changes in her previous positions, she skillfully avoided answering a number of important questions about her supposed evolution.
Good politicians are famous for such things. A lack of answers, or oblique references and generalized statements, are usually a sure sign that a politician’s policies are wisely disguised for the purposes of public consumption. Harris didn’t answer sufficiently how her economic plan, her history as the border czar, and her propensity to favor governmental solutions for most issues differ at all from than the Biden administration’s, of which she has been an integral part for the past four years.
Has she truly evolved to be a mainstream stateswoman, or is she still a political progressive, which she has proudly identified as for most of her political life?
If she is no longer as ultra-liberal as she has been in the past, then I would like to see Vice President Harris consent to some tough interviews where she would be challenged to explain her political evolution. I suspect she won’t do so if she can avoid it. To not do so makes it very hard for me to vote for her.
I’m sorry that Donald Trump is dodging attacks because of the perception that the media, and he himself at times, has created. I’m also disappointed that Kamala Harris has dodged the probing questions of a media that ought to be challenging her to be transparent about her would-be policies.
It’s what wrong about our politics and our media today. Whether it was Commander Oliver Perry during the War of 1812, or Pogo the comic, who both said, “We have met the enemy and they are ours (or us).” Abraham Lincoln said much the same in an 1838 speech: “America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves.”
None of us want that to happen.
In this remarkably tight race for president, can either candidate emerge from the protective bubble of campaign handlers and the amen-chorus of their own political tribe to reassure me they see a way forward that can unite and not divide us further? If and then, one of them may still get my vote.
Your thoughts? I expect I’ll hear many at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
