“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
—First Amendment
The First Amendment was added to the U.S. Constitution to preserve individual liberties and limit the power of the government — giving Americans the right to even challenge the laws and the rules that governing bodies make.
The administration of the University of Nevada, Reno, and its women’s volleyball team are in the midst of just such a classic match of wills between conscience and the law. The passionate back-and-forth volley between both sides is not only making for interesting reading; it cuts to the genius of American democracy.
In the case of the Nevada Wolf Pack team and a majority of its women athletes, their grievances stem from a vote among players to forfeit an Oct. 26 match against San José State and a transgender player on its roster. The team’s statement on the issue was as follows: “We, the University of Nevada Reno women’s volleyball team, forfeit against San Jose State University and stand united in solidarity with the volleyball teams of Southern Utah University, Boise State University, the University of Wyoming, and Utah State University … We demand that our right to safety and fair competition on the court be upheld. We refuse to participate in any match that advances injustice against female athletes.”
The university responded with a carefully worded statement by President Brian Sandoval, a former federal judge, saying: “As a public university, we are legally prohibited by the Nevada Constitution and other laws and regulations (by the NCAA) to declare a forfeit for reasons related to gender identity or expression.” He also pointed out that “(t)he University acknowledges that a student athlete’s refusal to participate in the match with San José State University can be interpreted as free expression that is protected by the First Amendment of the United States Constitution.”
While UNR’s president has brilliantly threaded the legal arguments, this campus issue is fast becoming a prickly sticking point that promises to extend the match between conscience and the law into the equivalent of overtime sets with an uncertain outcome at this point.
It’s not the first time in American sports history that the issue of athletic activism and free speech has collided with the norms and the rules of those institutions that sponsor sports. Racial barrier-busting MLB player Jackie Robinson joined picket lines and attended civil rights rallies. Heavyweight boxing campion Muhammad Ali refused to join into the Armed Forces when drafted during the Vietnam War. Tennis star Billie Jean King, almost a year before the Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade ruling, signed an ad in the first issue of Ms. Magazine headlined with “We Have Had Abortions,” speaking out for reproductive rights for women. The list goes on.
And sometimes too — do the consequences of social activism and civil disobedience.
Martin Luther King understood firsthand the consequences of endorsing civil disobedience. Still, he did so, “to arouse the conscience of the community over injustice,” saying that at times; “One has not only a legal but a moral responsibility to obey just laws. Conversely, one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws.”
One of the issues that a majority of Nevada’s women’s volleyball team feels is unjust to them is to have to compete against a player on the hardcourt who was born a biological male, but now identifies as a female. The issue of transgender athletes competing in college and high school sports has become a contentious fairness and safety issue, especially for many female athletes.
The “safety” issue in women’s sports have seen female athletes injured by larger, stronger transgender opponents. Payton McNabb was a high school volleyball player in North Carolina who suffered a concussion when she was spiked in the face by a transgender athlete. Speaking to the issue before a congressional hearing on “The Fairness in Women’s Sports Act,” McNabb testified: “I suffered from a concussion and a neck injury that to this day I am still recovering from. Other injuries I still suffer from today include impaired vision, partial paralysis on my right side, constant headaches, as well as anxiety and depression.”
Opponents of trans players competing in female sports cite the Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science report that concluded, “Males and females are physically different, and males have a category-level athletic advantage.” Recent polls suggest that the American public agrees. A 2023 Gallup Study found that “a larger majority of Americans now (69%) than in 2021 (62%) say transgender athletes should only be allowed to compete on sports teams that conform with their birth gender. Likewise, fewer endorse transgender athletes being able to play on teams that match their current gender identity, 26%, down from 34%.”
Still, the law is the law, or at least until it’s changed. If women’s teams continue to forfeit games against transgender opponents, the NCAA may be forced to reexamine its policies. If so, it will have been the result of student activism, as demonstrated by those like Nevada’s women’s volleyball team.
William Block is a sports expert and attorney who recently resigned as a longtime NCAA committee member. He’s spearheading a lawsuit against the college governing body, saying in a recent Wall Street Journal opinion column, “A pluralistic society depends on an attitude of live and let live, and American adults are and should be free to make their own choices about gender. But what many people resent is having progressive cultural values imposed on them. That includes compelling their daughters to compete against athletes who were born male.”
UNR president Brian Sandoval was correct to underscore the rights and responsibilities of both the institution and the students that he leads. The court of public opinion has a way of sorting these things out. The middle path of a wise leader may allow such a pathway to be found.
In my opinion, Nevada women’s volleyball doesn’t need opportunistic attorneys with questionable abilities and political motives like Joey Gilbert trying to glom on to an issue for personal notoriety. The First Amendment has more than enough stature to embolden both administrators and student athletes to find the right balance. Students in the prime of their young lives have frequently shown a path for the betterment of society, even when it went against the sentiments of the established order.
A few years ago there was a student initiative to place a statue of Colin Kaepernick on the UNR campus, honoring his social stands and First Amendment rights. President Sandoval has since wisely tabled that issue. Besides, another statue might have to be erected alongside Kaepernick’s, honoring the brave stance of UNR female athletes.
The First Amendment invites each of us to stand on principle and conscience when it comes to laws and the institutions that support them. It’s important to honor the sacredness of individual’s opinions — even when you don’t agree with the stand being taken.
Kudos to the young women of the University of Nevada, Reno, for showing that strength and skills are not just something to be exhibited on the volleyball court.
They are showing Nevadans what courage can do in the court of public opinion as well.
Your thoughts? Email me at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
