You would think that public school teachers’ unions would love public charter schools. After all, teachers and their unions were the earliest supporters of charter schools that give flexibility to teachers and the autonomy to design classroom instruction that best serves children’s needs.
In 1988, at the time the innovative idea of a different kind of public school was first experimented with, Albert Shanker, National President of the American Federation of Teachers, called for the reform of traditional public schools by establishing “schools of choice.” He envisioned a hybrid form of public schools, free from many state laws and district regulations, making them more accountable for student outcomes. In a 2014 New York Times Sunday Review retrospective look at the school reformer, he was said to have “outlined an idea for a new kind of public school where teachers could experiment with fresh and innovative ways to reach students.” Shanker imagined charter schools as “high-performing educational laboratories from which traditional public schools could learn.”
So what’s the problem? Why now does virtually every teachers’ union and many of their almost exclusively Democratic supporters so vehemently oppose charter schools? The answer: Most public charter teachers don’t unionize and teachers’ unions don’t benefit from them paying dues that increasingly go towards their political priorities. Charters are also increasingly attracting families to their classrooms as evidenced by the fact that state charters schools in Nevada now comprise the equivalent of the second-largest school system in the state.
Teachers’ unions’ political spending
According to Open Secrets, a research firm that tracks money in U.S. politics, “Teachers unions have steadily amped up their political involvement. From 2004 to 2016, their donations grew from $4.3 million to more than $32 million — an all-time high, giving Democrats at least 94 percent of the funds they contributed to candidates and parties since as far back as 1990, where our data begins.”
The largest teachers’ union, the National Education Association, with which Nevada’s statewide union (NSEA) and the Washoe Education Association are affiliated, has prioritized political spending over member representational expenditures, according to its most recent annual federal disclosure, which covered September 2022 through August 2023. The NEA spent more than $50 million on what it self-reports as “political activities and lobbying” compared to around $39 million on representational activities. Additionally, about $126 million was spent on “contributions, gifts and grants,” of which a good amount went to left-wing political organizations, including groups who then funnel donations to support Democratic candidates. This doesn’t even take into account the millions of dollars that went to NEA’s political action committee.
While it’s understood that institutions give rise to vested interests, it makes sense that union leaders would pursue policies that enhance their members job security, increase wages and benefits and in countless ways protect or advance the job interests of their members.
But why the gigantic political candidate spending that’s larger then what they spend on representing and supporting members job security and benefits?
Institutions give rise to vested interests. Politics are the means by which an organization ensures power for the organization’s special interests. As political science professor Terry Moe of Stanford’s Hoover Institute has written in his book, “The Politics of Institutional Reform,” “When people and organizations have vested interests in a given institutional system, they tend to see almost all efforts at institutional change — as disruptive to the source of their benefits.”
In other words, teachers’ unions are losing dues-paying membership to charter schools that don’t unionize and districts are losing students and teachers to alternative publicly-funded better-performing charter schools — especially in areas where districts schools are underperforming.
Charter school results
As Forbes Magazine recently found, “In an era of stagnating educational achievement and bloated public school budgets, America’s education system is in dire need of innovation. Despite strong opposition from entrenched interests, the growth in charter schools exemplifies educational innovation in cities and towns across the country.
“Charter schools receive public funding but are independently operated. With more flexibility, they provide a worthwhile alternative to traditional district schools.”
With small independent school boards, they focus on the academic needs of students in their individual schools and not necessarily the cookie-cutter policies that are necessarily made in large school districts.
The proof is in the performance pudding.
Data from the latest Nevada School Performance Rankings from the Department of Education, over half (52%) of state-sponsored public charter schools are rated either 5-star (“superior school that exceeds expectations”) or 4-star (“commendable school that has performed well for all students and subgroups). Compare that to the average for traditional Nevada district schools that have over half (56%) of students rated as 1-star (“school that has not met the state’s standard of performance”) or 2-star (school that has partially met standard of performance).
It’s little wonder there are thousands of students in Nevada who are on charter school waiting lists. People who are leaving traditional political parties are voting with their feet. Parents, either Democrats or Republicans, are looking for alternatives for their children’s education and are “voting” by their choice of different educational outcomes. It’s disconcerting for the education establishment. I get that.
The dilemma for education
Teachers’ union pioneer Albert Shanker understood it as well. In a surprisingly candid Pew Forum speech in 1993, Shanker commented, “We are at the point that the auto industry was at a few years ago. They could see they were losing market share every year and still not believe that it really had anything to do with the quality of the product … I think we will get — and deserve — the end of public education if we don’t behave differently.”
It why it’s a fool’s errand for State Sen. Skip Daly of Sparks, a retired union leader, to continuously try to legislatively prevent charters schools from expanding — or even continue to exist — in Nevada. Together with the Washoe County Education Association (which is suing the City of Reno over the expansion of an approved and successful charter school, Mater Academy, from expanding to areas with underserved students and underperforming schools in the North Valleys), Daley and teachers’ union officials are swimming upstream against the current of educational choice. I predict most, if not all, of Daley’s anti-charter school bills this session won’t pass before sine die of the Nevada Legislature.
As education reformer Thomas Sowell has said, “Schools exist for children. Schools do not exist for the education of children. Schools do not exist to provide iron-clad jobs for teachers, billions of dollars in union dues for teachers’ unions, monopolies for educational bureaucracies, a guaranteed market for teachers’ college degrees or a captive audience for indoctrinators.”
I was there in 1997 and voted in support of the Democrat and Republican lawmakers in the Legislature who offered their bipartisan support for the creation of public charters schools in Nevada. Serving on the Education Committee every session I served in the Assembly and on the State Board of Education when I was appointed by Brian Sandoval, I supported successful education models and their funding. As a columnist I have always celebrated the good things the excellent teachers and principals that are part of the WCSD have accomplished on behalf of their students.
It’s because I support education and how we can improve the opportunities for parents and their students to succeed in Nevada, that I support public charter schools.
Teachers’ unions would do well to learn that lesson as well from their prominent founder, along with the sentiments of a growing number of Nevada families.
Your thoughts are welcome as always at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
