Sadly, the proliferation of new media sources — minus traditional journalistic guardrails — has contributed to the growing distrust of news accounts that are full of misinformation, disinformation, and even “fake news.”
In last week’s Memo from the Middle, I suggested that with all the turkey and football consumption over the Thanksgiving weekend, it would be a good idea to “hit the pause button.” Go out in nature and spend some time reflecting on where it is you have been, and where it is you are going.
Heeding my own holiday advice, I went hiking on the Friday after turkey day with my longtime reporter friend, Sean. Stuffed from all the trimmings and my wife’s cream cheese pumpkin pie topped with whipped cream, it was a wise dietary decision to drag myself up a trail near Mt. Rose.
On the day after Thanksgiving, one thing is certain: You won’t be alone in a shopping mall, or on most hiking trails. Rather than hitting the pause button, it seemed most post-holiday hikers were pressing “fast-forward” in hopes of shedding their blues and a few excess pounds on the trail past Dry Lake.
Spending most Fridays hiking — as Sean and I have been doing fairly religiously since Covid — we invariably get into long and sometimes heated conversations during even the coldest of walks. Just like when we did a “Walkabout and Talk-About Around Lake Tahoe” for the RGJ a few years ago, we end up talking about everything imaginable under the sun, and beyond.
What got me heated up this past week on the chilly north side of the trail we were climbing was Sean’s mention that he had recently seen on social media — on X, formerly Twitter — that a certain worldwide figure he knows I admire was, in fact, “a CIA agent.” Having just finished reading a book written by the Dalai Lama describing the ordeal he and his countrymen have endured following his exile from his native land some 66 years ago, I wasn’t prepared to accept the allegation my former reporter friend had read somewhere while scrolling through his social media feed.
This led us into such a vigorous discussion of “media believability” that it felt like the almost three-hour hike was over before it got started. Both having been reporters over the last 30 years, we had plenty to argue about.
Good news and bad news
According to the Pew Research Center, up until the early 1970s, “Most Americans expressed a high degree of trust in the news, even though their choices were limited. American households got their news from one of the three major broadcast networks on television or on the radio, and from their local newspaper, which carried a mixture of national and local headlines.”
By the 1980s, 24-hour news platforms like CNN began to change all that. According to Pew, “The 1990s saw the emergence of a set of powerful national media brands that would offer alternatives to Americans who wanted something different.
‘The Rush Limbaugh Show,’ nationally syndicated in 1988, put conservative talk radio on the map. In the mid-1990s, Fox News debuted, combining CNN’s always-on news and commentary approach with a distinctly conservative voice. MSNBC showed up on the cable dial that same year and soon carved out a liberal niche in response to Fox.”
Beginning in the 21st century, a new bumper crop of internet companies came along dispensing digital versions that promised to deliver a kind of “democratization” of news through greater accessibility and more diverse voices. Sadly, the proliferation of new media sources — minus traditional journalistic guardrails — has contributed to the growing distrust of news accounts that are full of misinformation, disinformation, and even “fake news.”
The result? News-seeking Americans have barricaded themselves into partisan political silos, picking and choosing news accounts that reinforce their own views and marginalize those they disagree with.
As the Pew study found, “The rapid rise of social media as a source of news has shaped public attitudes about journalism. Research has found that social media use has led to burnout and news avoidance and fuels general mistrust of all media.” And while a majority of Americans now turn to social media as a source of news, they are even more wary of these platforms than they are of professional news organizations, according to Pew.
It shows up in the way Americans’ confidence in the media has sunk to historic lows. According to a recent 2025 Gallup survey, “Only 28% expressed a ‘great deal’ or ‘fair amount’ of trust in newspapers, television and radio to report the news fully, accurately and fairly.”
Gallup concluded by noting, “With confidence fractured along partisan and generational lines, the challenge for news organizations is not only to deliver fair and accurate reporting but also to regain credibility across an increasingly polarized and skeptical public.”
Ain’t that the truth. Then again, I’m telling you what you already know.
Believe everything,
or believe nothing?
Getting back to the shock of the “social media” revelation from my hiking buddy, I was faced with a dilemma. Should I do like many people and “believe” everything or nothing that I consume from the media? Or is there a “middle way,” as the Tibetan monk suggests?
Let me tell you what I did when I heard something from my friend that I found hard to believe. Following are my thoughts on what to do when we are faced with the challenge of being either a believer or a nonbeliever in respect to what the media says and does.
First, read it. Then check the sources of the story itself.
Are there reputable news organizations that carried the article, or was it only on “social media”?
Was there more than one story done by different news outlets?
Were the sources corroborated or denied what was reported?
Did the “subject” of the news story acknowledge or deny the story?
Something else that is equally important — how recent did the supposed facts of the story take place? Finally, and most importantly, what is the context of the story itself?
In the case of the figure I’m referencing from the “X/Twitter feed” that alleged the aging 91-year-old Buddhist cleric is a “CIA agent,” he, in fact, said, “I am not.” Upon a deeper dive into the numerous news accounts of the alleged association, the religious figure did acknowledge that his exiled organization received funds between the 1950s and 1970s from CIA sources during a period when the imperialistic aims of conquering Tibet by the Chinese Communist government clashed with the anti-communist sentiments of American administrations during that same period.
Instead of believing or disbelieving something because someone said it was posted online somewhere, I checked it out for myself by reading numerous articles and first-person accounts. I also looked for context — and I found it in at least enough sources to satisfy my concerns.
What is the lesson for today’s media consumers with such a large smorgasbord of media morsels to choose from — some tainted and some true? Look to more than one source for your news. If you are a conservative, read and watch liberal media outlets. If you are liberal, do the same in order to understand where conservatives are coming from.
I’d advise you to search as well for the gray areas and not just the black-and-white echoes of your preconceived notions.
To decide to believe, or not believe, what the media tells you requires making extra efforts these days if you are truly interested in finding truthful news accounts.
Don’t you think so? At: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
