The present predicament in the Middle East can best be explained by the motto of the University of Virginia’s Center for Politics: “Those who look into the crystal ball of politics (and predict) are destined to eat crushed glass.”

It’s true, no one can predict the outcome of yet another conflict in the Middle East. According to my artificially intelligent friends online, pinpointing the exact number of wars in the Middle East in the last 100 years is difficult to determine because of “the high frequency of conflicts.”

Here we are again. The stage is set, and the actors from both Israel and Iran have invited the U.S. to once again to play a leading role on an uncertain world stage.

I know I’m no more qualified to tell you “what” or “how” to think about the current events in the Mideast than I am to tell you when you should have planted your tomato garden this season — regardless of what day the snow finally melted on Peavine Peak.

No crystal ball here. Just some wishful thinking from a person who tries to see the glass half-full rather than half-empty, whenever I can.

Having gone to the Middle East on fact-finding tours to Israel, Gaza, Jordan and Turkey, I came away seeing potential forces developing in the cradle of the world’s civilizations that give me hope. While it appears ancient animosities keep returning us to the missile-laden nights of armed conflicts; there also appears to be a dawn of sorts in the growing acceptance, and even cooperation, evolving between certain descendants of the three Abrahamic faiths.

In both Jerusalem and Istanbul, I witnessed relationships between Jews, Christians and Muslims of good will engaged not just in dialogue, but in actual institution-building projects with each other. Having the same root of their historic faiths has helped them to seek ways in which the blossoming of their various religious branches produces seeds for peaceful futures.

Religion is good — theocracies are awful

One of the things that impressed me during my stay in Israel was both the religious pluralism and the political diversity I saw there. I visited neighborhoods in Jerusalem where the members of the three Abrahamic religions live and worship side-by-side. I observed Israeli Arab members serving in the Knesset (Israel’s parliament). Being a tourist in bustling Tel Aviv, I saw more secular liberalism on display than symbols of religious conservatism. Such differences exist in healthy societies.

The United States was born after rejecting any “church-state” form of government. Thomas Jefferson sought to create a “wall of separation between Church & State,” rejecting the historical entanglement of government and religion he believed denied people a fundamental right of conscience and the right to think and decide for oneself so essential to a republic.

The experiment of the United States as a democratic republic has been successful because freedom of faith and conscience has been its cornerstone. It’s why Americans of every sensible religious and political persuasion condemned the agenda-driven murder of Minnesota lawmakers by a fanatical religious and political extremist.

That’s not the case for the current Islamic regime in Iran, that is predicated on a radicalized political version of Islam. It’s why the current government in Iran, is likely to end up on the disappearing side of history.

Religiously radical Iran will eventually fail

Iran, once known as Persia, has a truly glorious past. The Arabic media network Al Jazeera says about the country’s history: “Iran’s history spans millennia, making it one of the world’s most ancient and culturally rich nations, continuously inhabited and influential throughout history.”

With a population of 92 million, Iran is the 17th-largest country in the world by population and land area. Iran’s nominal gross domestic product ranks it 36th in terms of the economy size. The country is rich in oil and gas, ranking as the world’s ninth-largest oil producer and third-largest natural gas producer.

Iran is home to one of the world’s oldest continuous major civilizations, with historical and urban settlements dating back to 4000 BC, and with a storied history of religious tolerance. Cyrus the Great, the founder of the Persian Empire, is remembered in Jewish tradition for his benevolent policies towards the Jewish people after conquering the Babylonian Empire.

In the modern era, pro-Western forces embodied by the Shah of Iran were in power until the 1979 Islamic revolution led by the Ayatollah Khomeini, who toppled the American-supported Iranian leader. Radical Islamic extremists subsequently kidnapped 66 U.S. citizens that same year and were held hostage before being released minutes before Ronald Reagan’s inauguration in 1981.

Ever since Iran’s theocratic regime consolidated its power, the Iranian population itself has grown increasingly weary of Islamic religious practices (clothing restrictions for women, etc.) being systematically imposed on its citizens.

The Netherlands-based Gamaan Institute conducted a public survey in December of 2023 of 158,000 people living in Iran. The poll showed that “more than 80 percent of respondents reject the Islamic Republic and prefer a democratic government.”

With such widespread lack of support for the Islamic regime, especially among younger Iranians, it’s a festering problem for the aging religious mullahs who control the country. According to figures from the United Nations Statistics Division, “nearly 60 percent of Iran’s population are under the age of 39.” And they are not happy.

Whether it amounts to another revolution of sorts to change the religious-dominated government remains to be seen. The recent military attacks by Israel and the U.S. may up the chances that “Game of Thrones”-like factions emerge within the Iranian government hoping to get ahead of any changes that might result from the present turmoil.

Changes in the Middle East

While it’s too early to know or predict any change that might or might not take place in Iran, it is possible to observe growing trends in other parts of the Middle East.

President Donald Trump’s speeches are often bombastic and frequently self-serving, especially when wrapped in his America-first rhetoric. But in a foreign policy address delivered in Saudi Arabia earlier this year, the U.S. president’s remarks appeared to have struck a chord with some Mideast countries that appear to be pursuing his theme of “commerce over chaos.”

“The gleaming marvels of Riyadh and Abu Dhabi were not created by the so-called nation builders, neocons or liberal nonprofits like those who spent trillions and trillions of dollars failing to develop other countries,” Trump said, speaking to a largely Arab audience. “Instead, the birth of a modern Middle East has been brought by the people of the region themselves by developing your own sovereign countries, pursuing your own unique visions and charting your own destinies in your own way.”

I hope the president listens to himself and doesn’t try to be either be a nation builder or nation destroyer of Iran. It’s up to the Iranian people to determine their own fate. History would seem to indicate that they have it within themselves to do so. It may not be pretty. Revolutions rarely are.

What the U.S and Israel are doing by denying nuclear armaments to a group of religious fanatics intent on being a jihad factory should result in a safer world.

When twisting the arm of a bully until they cry “uncle,” the bully may finally get it and begin to change itself.

Crystal ball or not, I hope so. Your thoughts? Send them to me at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.