“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness …”
And so it may seem for our beloved America today.
The long opening sentence of Charles Dickens’ “A Tale of Two Cities” is among the most well-remembered lines in literature. As much as it was about a time in history when the Reign of Terror was engulfing France, it was also a story of enduring human connections and resilience amidst chaos.
In the sad and tumultuous times we are living through as Americans, it’s beginning to look like we are weaving our own tale of a country hopelessly dividing into two. The only way out from our “winter of despair,” as Dickens wrote, may be in a coming “spring of hope.”
The U.S. is more divided now along ideological and political lines than at any time since the 1850s. A recent article from Chatham House, an international policy institute, warned about the potential for a “national divorce” in the United States: “The emergent two Americas can also be seen across a range of divisive social issues that reflect deeper divisions than those that merely manifest themselves at the ballot box.”
Progressive political pundit Michael Podhorzer argues that the United States has always been more like two nations tenuously united under the Constitution: “These ‘red and blue nations’ … are divided by geography, by political economy, and by different views toward religion and even democracy itself.”
Conservative political commentator Dennis Prager sees the U.S. in a different light because of what he calls “the uniqueness of America’s value system.” Prager points to the three engravings on American coins: “E Pluribus Unum,” “In God We Trust,” and “Liberty” as evidence of exceptional American values.
Here is a test for you to take: After just reading the previous two commentaries (one progressive, one conservative), if you believe deeply in one viewpoint, and abhor the other, then you can see proof of the growing divide we are witnessing that is currently spilling over into both political and religious violence in the country.
God, or humanism, please help us.
One country — different meanings
Dr. Ryan Dawkins taught classes for years at the U.S. Air Force Academy. He writes: “Partisans from each party are operating in very different political realities and misunderstand their fellow Americans on even a basic level. People are no longer operating from a position where, despite whatever differences may exist, they still share a common identity as Americans. Even though we all ostensibly share the common label ‘American,’ the norms and stereotypes associated with what it means to be American could not be more different.”
The question to me is, are we really that “different” from one another as Americans? Or, are we just not understanding our differences because we are not listening because in part, because we are so desperate to be heard? It seems we are too often not practicing the best rules of engagement when comes to politics and many of our interactions. As American self-help guru Stephen Covey always reminded his audiences, “Seek first to understand, then to be understood.”
For over 70 years the Aspen Institute has gathered American thought leaders to understand what is at the core of American’s most cherished values. Partnering with the Gallup Organization, they came up recently with an “American Values Index.” What they found was a broad moral consensus: “Vast majorities of Americans regard family, respect, trustworthiness, freedom and kindness as important values.”
Whether or not those common bonds personally can turn into common ground politically remains to be seen. But it’s something some Americans are trying to do.
We’re taking a stand against toxic politics
I’m now a nonpartisan voter, like a growing number of Nevadans, according to the latest 2025 Nevada Secretary of State voter registration rolls. Nonpartisans and others now outnumber, with a 40% voter registration share, both Democrats and Republicans who currently enjoy just a 30% share each of registered voters.
It’s also why I was curious to attend a 15-person gathering of Nevadans this past Saturday at a local Reno library under the auspices of an organization called “Braver Angels.” They say they are “taking a stand against toxic politics” by leading a nationwide cross-partisan stand in order to “bridge the partisan divide and strengthen our democratic republic.” They hope that by sponsoring a number of free online courses on subjects like: Skills for Bridging the Divide, Depolarizing Within and Managing Difficult Conversations, they believe they can help people “disagree better.”
Besides creating civil dialogues between persons with differing political views, I was pleased to see two University of Nevada, Reno professors in attendance. The were interested in learning how to foster greater dialogue between students of different political persuasions inside the classroom and beyond.
Building on our foundational values
Being a child of the 1960s, I recall the oft-referred cliche, “You are what you eat.” More than merely a reference to food consumption and its effects upon your overall health, the ’60s slogan referred also to what you “take in” with regard to the view of how a person sees his or herself.
One of my favorite quotes is by diary writer Anaïs Nin. She understood what makes up the core of foundational values, saying, “We don’t see things as they are, we see them as we are.”
Our core beliefs — whether they are rooted in theism, humanism, or atheism — contribute greatly to how we see and relate to others. America’s founding Declaration, penned by Thomas Jefferson, underscored that the foundational values of “life, liberty and pursuit of happiness” that we all seek, could best be realized when it’s rooted in a common source (Creator) that serves as the basis for how we widely see ourselves and the society and governments we create.
Dr. Frank Kaufmann, a Vanderbilt University Ph.D. who heads a faith-based organization called the Settlement Project, sees the value of having a spiritual worldview, benefitting those who hold such beliefs, saying, “Affirming God is actually expressing faith that reality is imbued with benevolence and hope. God-fearing people trust in the effectiveness of kindness and forgiveness.”
It’s darkest before the dawn
Dickens was right to say it remains to be seen if we live in the “best of times, or the worst of times.” Whether we continue in a season of “Darkness,”or turn it into a time of “Light,” depends on a lot of things, but especially — each of us.
I personally, don’t want to live in an America comprised of two countries.
If we return to the place that we are all “out of many, one” as Americans, we may see the beginning of a new dawn of hope after a period of one hell of a current dark night.
Your thoughts are welcome, as always, at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
