Most “larger than life” persons are just that. When the final epitaph is written, the image they tried to create for themselves makes those men’s lives appear anything but large in terms of the lasting legacy they leave behind.
Bill Paganetti, co-founder of the Peppermill Resort, was different. The more you examine the quiet unassuming things he did for his community, his family, and his employees, the more a larger-than-life image of a humble son of a feed store owner from Petaluma, California, emerges. As Warren Buffett once put it, “Coming from nowhere is a badge of honor compared to being a member of the lucky sperm club” (aka the elite). Bill’s hardworking father would sometimes toss cold water on his young son if he slept in too long, neglecting his duties to feed the family’s chickens in the working-class town once dubbed the “egg capital of the world.”
Bill’s legendary work ethic was hatched there in Petaluma along with his lifelong friendship with business partner Nat Carasali. Having gone to elementary, high school and college together, the two men — from mothers who once worked together as maids at a Petaluma motel — would start their business partnership building homes at Lake Tahoe.
Finally in 1971, Bill and Nat bought a small restaurant and lounge on South Virginia Street they dubbed “The Peppermill.” The rest as they say, is the lore that legends are made of.
Even into his 80s, Bill could be found most days walking around his beloved casino wearing his signature black T-shirt, sweater and dark denim jeans, talking to customers and employees of the Reno mega resort. Bill’s legendary blue collar (or no-collar) look belies an image of a casino visionary that now has more than 5,000 employees amidst its meticulously designed and maintained properties.
After he passed, I sat down with three of the persons closest in life to Bill: his parish priest, his son, and his business partner. Each talked about what Paganetti called the three “pillars” of life: his faith, his family, and his Peppermill.
Father Tony Vercellone, parish priest:
“When I first met Bill, I had no idea he was the owner. He was a generous and quiet giver. He never gave so that he could receive the accolades or credit. With his sense of belief and being hospitable, miracles happened … A little coffee shop turned into a famous hotel spa.
“Bill was always on the go. He’d walk around the Peppermill with his yellow pad and write down all the things that needed to be done. I hope Jesus has plenty of yellow pads in heaven (laughing). So much of his kind and generous nature was carried over into his business and directed towards his employees, In that humanness, there was also a holiness. The lesson I get from Bill’s life is: ‘Can we be as giving to one another without it being an ego trip?’ Bill is the kind of person that our world needs in these times of division.”
Billy Paganetti, his son:
“My dad and I have always been extremely close. One of the highlights of my life has been getting to work with him for the past 17 years. I’m amazed at the amount of time he spent with me. He was never one who said, ‘I’ve had enough, I need to go to sleep because I have to work tomorrow.’ He was always there for me.”
“He taught me about life and business, saying there are three fatal flaws in both: temper, greed, and ego. Once outside a restaurant in San Francisco before a 49ers game, he gave money to a homeless man and said to me, ‘See him, you are no better than he. You both put your pants on one leg at a time.’ The same day he told me when I got excited about seeing Joe Montana: ‘He’s no better than you are.’ It’s always stuck with me that my dad never felt he was better than anybody else. He had an old-school work ethic and valued treating people the right way. The family used to say, the Peppermill was his ‘sixth kid.’ He spent most of his time there. He loved the employees and appreciated them down to the very last person. I don’t think my dad ever put a golf club in his hands. His hobby and love was his business. He loved the day-to-day grind.
“My dad wasn’t one to preach. He was never one to push his faith on anyone else. He was kind and generous and didn’t want his name on a lot of the things he did. One of my favorite memories of my father was him in his 80s driving to Petaluma a couple of times a week (he wouldn’t use the Peppermill plane because he didn’t think it was proper) just to visit his dying brother, Kenny — in order to comfort and massage him.
“He never forgot his roots, and the things his parents and grandparents taught him. Just walking into the Peppermill, it’s going to be hard not to think of him.”
Nat Caraseli, business partner and friend:
“Bill’s parents and mine were friends before we were born. After all we have been through, we’d sometimes say to each other, ‘How in the hell did we do it?’ Bill always wanted us reinventing and reinvesting in ourselves. He was a visionary who could see what we were capable of becoming.
“For 50 years we shared an office together. My desk on one side, his on the other. When I look across the room today, I don’t see him. I can’t imagine (wistfully) life without him.”
And so do many of the employees — some who have been working there since they were kids. James Moritz started at the Peppermill as a teenage bus boy. Forty-five years later, Jim is the assistant general manager.
“Bill was the owner, but he didn’t act like the owner,” Moritz said. “He had the leadership thing that people talk about but can’t live up to. Bill didn’t have to talk about it, he embodied it. I feel sorry for the Pearly Gates — they are going to get a remodel and it’s going to get done in three weeks!” he laughed.
Mike Johnson is now the executive chef. He too, started at the Peppermill 45 years ago busing tables. About his boss: “Bill’s care for his employees was always No. 1 to him. I’m going to miss seeing him and our day-to-day interactions.”
At at time when public figures frequently embellish their image with braggadocios behavior and pettiness, it’s refreshing to find a leader who is known for his quiet acts of kindness and devotion to the timeless things he found most important.
A truly great person is best defined by what others say about him or her.
Bill Paganetti qualifies. His devotion to his faith, his family, and his beloved Peppermill may just well reserve that forever table in the Fireside Lounge of his dreams.
Please share your impressions or experiences: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
