Traveling by ship these past two weeks through Greece and Italy and the ancient city-states that make up much of Western antiquity, I couldn’t help but wonder how America will be remembered some 2,000 years from now. Will we be thought of for our once-illustrious past like our Greek and Roman predecessors, or will we be lauded for all we’ve yet to accomplish?
I’m sure America will be known for our mostly noble past. But I hope it also will be for meeting the global challenges that occupy our turbulent present, and for a future path we’ve shown the world on just how humanity succeeds. As it always has been, much will depend on what we do with our freedoms, and the responsibilities that go along with our citizenship.
My recent trip taught me a lot. I learned Americans are easy to pick out by our foreign hosts. Tour guides routinely recognize Americans because of their inquisitiveness and good-natured banter. In past travels, younger tour leaders would frequently steal away for a sidebar conversation about the joys of visiting, or even immigrating to America.
It was not the case with this trip.
In fact, two different younger Europeans charged with extolling the virtues of their own countries told me of their disappointments with mine. One of them, Janez, a high school science teacher from Slovenia, spoke with me after we had finished a walk through the cobblestone streets of Koper, an old capitol city under the once-mighty Venetian Republic.
The first words of greeting out of Janez’s mouth to our tour group of mostly elderly Americans was an unsolicited lecture on what people like himself think of the current situation in the United States. A 20-year summer tour guide, Janez began by saying, “You Americans must be curious what we think about you.” Saying that whenever he mentions Melania Trump, the wife of the former president, who was born in Slovenia, he immediately sees a divide emerge among Americans who either snicker or smile at the mere mention of her name.
“I see the side-glares and a kind of cynicism I’ve never witnessed before from Americans,” he said.
Having grown up in former communist Yugoslavia, Janez worries that what he is seeing among Americans today are familiar signs of heightened tensions and divisions that turned into brutal wars in the Balkan region during the 1990s. He told me he hopes that the kind of distrust of each other that he’s viewing among Americans won’t lead to the kind of societal implosions that rocked the Balkan states when he was a young person.
“I saw from my childhood what happens when people start ‘balkanizing’ against each other,” he recalled.
America has sought to avoid such a phenomena. For years, the country’s unofficial motto was “E pluribus unum” (“out of many, one”). It served as the north star of American idealism. As Yale scholar Amy Chua, author of “Political Tribes,” wrote, “Of all the nations in the world, none has succeeded more than the United States in bringing together immigrants from diverse backgrounds and joining them in a new identity — American.”
It’s why there is no greater threat to the future viability of this experiment we call America than for us to succumb to the divisive tendency my new friend from Slovenia warned about: the balkanization of the U.S. Should we continue identifying as hyphenated-Americans, sooner or later we may end up in the kind of tribal-like conflicts we’re already witnessing in the political arena.
America has worked to a large degree because of assimilation and tolerance. To become something less is to end up with a similar fate as the Yugoslavias of the world — or, at the very least, to be remembered for past, not present, greatness. As Winston Churchill pointed out, “The farther backward you look, the farther forward you are likely to see.”
Past American presidents have noted the wisdom of remaining united as a people, despite our unique differences. As Theodore Roosevelt once remarked, “We welcome the German or the Irishman who becomes an American. We have no use for the German or Irishman who remains such.” Even Barack Obama, himself a hyphenated-American, echoed a similar sentiment: “When I see Mexican flags waved at pro-immigration demonstrations, I sometimes feel a flush of patriotic resentment.”
We’ve been through tumultuous eras before as Americans. America has made it this far by cutting ties with the empire that once ruled us, by breaking the bonds of slavery that surely would have doomed us, and by facing down the crises of three world wars, both hot and cold, that challenged the very foundations of freedom. We navigated those daunting challenges in our history as Americans. We can do so again, if we avoid letting our differences seriously divide us.
It’s why the current tendency to fragment and devolve into tribal encampments sets the stage for present conflicts to turn into permanent fractures for a once united group of states.
Historian Neil Howe, in his new book on the cycles of history called “The Fourth Turning is Here,” warns that “Personal identity is likewise balkanizing into self-referential fortresses such as ethnicity, gender, religion, region, education and (of course) political party.” The result, as Howe sees it: “Americans are finding it harder to bear genuine diversity.”
I know what I’m saying may seem naïve and overly idealistic to many of you. I also understand that no one individual can tell the rest of the country what’s best for them. But I can tell you what I personally try to do in living up to the American ideal I feel fortunate to be pursuing.
I believe that the “self-evident truths” in the Declaration of Independence underscore that all of us are created equal and thus deserving of inalienable rights. In practice, it means whenever anyone writes me in reference to my views in this column, I feel I owe them respect and recognition, regardless of whether persons agree or disagree (which is frequently the case). In honest conversations with both my conservative and liberal friends, I come away learning something from each of them. Sometimes those discussions affirm my views. Sometimes, they even help me to change my perspective. In either case, I come away enriched.
America was once referred to as a melting pot. Some say we’re more like a salad bar these days. I prefer the former analogy because it shows how a little heat can meld things together, even if there remains a few lumps in the stew. It’s those “lumps” that gives our country its unique flavor and a lasting legacy.
Traveling abroad makes me appreciate home. This country is not only our home — it’s the place the world has previously looked towards to see what is humanly possible. The best parts of our heritage as Americans can last long into the future, if we live up to those lofty elements of what it means to be an American.
America doesn’t have to go the way of ancient Greece and Rome. Marcel Proust wrote that “what we call our future is the shadow that our past projects in front of us.”
America’s future is tied to our past — fast-forwarded to us in the present. We can find our future peace in our present circumstances, if we live up to the best ideals of our past.
Your thoughts? Email me at tahoeboy68@gmail.com,
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
