Tuesday’s vice presidential debate turned out be a fairly civil war between two candidates who, according to the Wall Street Journal Editorial Board, “put on a better, more informed, debate than their presidential running mates.” JD Vance and Tim Walz did in fact appear like two adults facing each other on stage as they debated.

The Hill, a top U.S. political website covering presidential campaigns, reported that “(t)he two candidates clashed on a range of issues, from abortion to immigration to foreign policy. But the forum was notably more civil and policy-focused than the debate between Vice President Harris and former President Trump that took place last month.”

It appears that the knack of being “Midwest Nice,” as one spin room prognosticator said, may have reassured at least some Americans that politics doesn’t always have to degenerate into the down and dirty. At times appearing to actually be listening to each other, and even disagreeing agreeably at some moments, both candidates gave more substantive answers than running mates Donald Trump and Kamala Harris offered up in their previous presidential slugfest. A not-so-casual observer like myself, after watching the two elected officials at times agreeably disagree, might have concluded that both candidates appeared as better spokespersons for their respective causes than the presidential contenders they were there to represent. Polls following the debate found both Democrats and Republicans were pleased with each candidate’s performance.

As the Wall Street Journal editorialized, “Americans were at least able to watch a substantive debate that came closer to revealing the election choice than anything their running mates have offered.”

Focus group guru Frank Luntz, in his post-debate analysis of the vice-presidential candidates’ performance in which his 14-member gathering of undecided voters, reported Vance was the winner over Walz by a 12-2 margin. The pollster even went so far as to say that “Donald Trump needs to speak less and let JD speak more.” Good luck with the prognostication that the former president would speak less. Still, he might be wise to. Then again, who tells Donald Trump what to do? Certainly not me.

With polls showing that Americans are still uncertain as to what Harris’ plans are should she become president; she might improve her chances if she spoke in more detail abut her would-be policies, as Tim Walz attempted to do. Unless of course, she’d rather not show her cards if she hopes people will vote for her simply because they don’t like Donald Trump.

Harris hasn’t done interviews with probing reporters and continues to dodge press questions. Some supporters I’ve spoken with are concerned that such a strategy is being perceived as a liability for the current vice president; and voters (especially undecided ones) might tend to choose someone whose positions they know, as opposed to someone’s they don’t.

With the American voting public as fickle and polarized as it is, it’s not a stretch to think they might vote for someone who they know what their policies are, as opposed to be wondering about them. Then again, “life is a box of chocolates,” as Forest Gump famously said. Fickle is as fickle does — when it comes to politics these days.

Both Trump and Harris have a record to run on, or to run from. He as president four years ago, she as vice president currently. Whether this becomes an election about change, as opposed to one about continuation, remains to be seen. Either way, it’s going to be close — and Nevada may very well end up being one of a handful of swing states that plays a decisive role in determining how much each presidential ticket’s past and present performance ends up shaping what the future holds.

Regardless of what the election outcome in Nevada be — and we may critical in the Electoral College equation — we won’t know the final tally any earlier than Nov. 10, when Nevada’s mail-in ballots finally will be announced.

Since I continue to be more worried about what happens in this country after the Nov. 5 election than I am with all that’s going on before it, it would be a relief if the two sides could be as respectful of each other in D.C. as Vance and Walz were on the debate stage in New York City.

Sometimes, I occasionally stumble across a bit of political wisdom hiking on Sierra Nevada trails with my hiking buddy and 25-year former political reporter, Sean Whaley. Last week near the top of Carson Pass, we discussed whether America is really in the middle of an “existential threat” to our very existence and survival as a republic. Both Sean’s and my conclusion: Like the cow pies and road apples (manure) we routinely transgress across, that idea is mostly “all bull…”

The two political parties, in my view, represent different sides of the American experiment. Just as there are multiple sides to the abortion issue, limits to government assistance and overreach, and America’s role on the ever-dangerous international stage, there ought to be a level of respect and even credence, given to each side’s approach to solutions.

JD Vance and Tim Walz showed it could be done on the debate stage for one night. The challenge for America is this: Can it be done for four years after another contentious election? Recently, we’ve not been very good at doing so.

I hope for the sake of our children and grandchildren that it can. As the Buffalo Springfield’s ’60s anthem “For What It’s Worth” sounded, “There’s battle lines being drawn. Nobody’s right if everybody’s wrong.”

Both sides can fear and fantasize about the existential threat each other poses. Or we can act like JD Vance and Tim Walz did, and agree to disagree and conclude with a pledge to shake hands and work together when the election dust has settled.

Is 2024 going to be a “choice” election? I believe so. The choice should be whether we are going to mend our fences as Americans, or continue to build walls between us that keep us warring against each other from inside our own political camps.

The two adults in the room at the vice presidential debate the other night showed us how it might be done. Now it’s our turn.

Your thoughts? Email me at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.

“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.