Taking on the 10 toughest topics to write about in “Memo from the Middle,” abortion tops the list both alphabetically and morally. A number of this column’s readers, including some of my closest friends, have questioned my sanity for even attempting such an impossible Don Quixote-like task.

The first two responses to “Nevadans need to talk about tough topics” (July 2) were: 1. Are you suicidal? 2. Have you increased your life insurance coverage? The answer is no. I do, however, understand there is no more polarizing issue in America than that of abortion. Evidence the reaction to the recent Supreme Court reversing Roe v. Wade, returning to individual states the power to regulate any aspect of abortion not protected by federal law.

There is a need for both sides of the abortion argument to lower the room temperature by attempting to listen and understand where the other side of the issue is coming from. What’s needed is a conversation around the best arguments of both sides. I know it’s a very sensitive subject, especially for women. The issue is also muddied by the semantics and word games that both sides employ.

The phrases “pro-life” and “pro-choice” are used in such a way as to make opponents appear either “anti-life” or “anti-choice.” Such labeling makes it harder to have a civil dialogue.

What are the best arguments of both sides of the debate? The National Right to Life organization says its mission is “to protect and defend the most fundamental right of humankind, the right to life of every innocent human being from the beginning of life to natural death.” On the other side, Planned Parenthood says their mission is “to ensure all people have access to the care and resources they need to make informed decisions about their bodies, their lives, and their futures.” Both positions are reasonable and worthy of respect, even if you’re not persuaded to change your own deeply held views.

The problem being, as one of the women readers of this column said to me, “Abortion and right to life issues are far more nuanced than is reflected in our public discourse.” Her understatement is echoed by pro-choice author Caitlin Flanagan in a 2019 essay for The Atlantic titled, “The Dishonesty of the Abortion Debate: Why we need to face the best arguments from the other side.” Conservative columnist George Will agrees how complex the issue is: “An ambivalent majority is permanently troubled by the irresolvable tension between a woman’s claim of personal autonomy and the inviolability of personhood.”

The question of a child’s “personhood” (or fetus’, as some would prefer) is something that even science has not been able to pull the curtain back on. Modern technology has made it possible to observe images never seen before. A 3-D ultrasound reveals a 12-week fetus has fingers and toes, eyelids and ears. Such photos make the child real for expecting parents, and harder to disregard as merely a clump of cells.

I’m aware that to have an abortion is the most difficult decision a woman may ever make. I’m not comfortable for a government on any level making that decision for a woman or her family. I also understand the role of politics in democracies and how this country has historically turned its moral priorities into law, as was the case with banning slavery in the 13th Amendment.

Personally, I’m saddened that abortions have become merely a gut-wrenching form of birth control for many women. I’m also sorry that so many children are born as accidents and not the product of love and intentional parenting. I wish that such an empowering alternative as adoption would be more positively looked upon.

Is it possible to be both pro-life and pro-choice — or at least respect the values of both? If we want to continue to live in a pluralistic society that’s so evenly divided over the issue of abortion, we will have to learn to understand and coexist with others who hold different views on life.

The abortion issue forces us to deal with our own humanity. It was Nelson Mandela who said, “There can be no keener revelation of a society’s soul than the way in which it treats its children.”

The pursuit of life, liberty and even happiness depends in part on how we bring children into our world, and how we care for them once we have.

“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.