Previously, America was described as

a melting pot.

The current analogy is closer to that of

a salad bar.

In the world’s first universal nation, America’s early motto was “e pluribus unum.” The Latin phrase means “out of many, one.” It represented not only how 13 different colonies emerged as a newly formed country, but how for the first time in history the United States was born as a nation entirely of immigrants from somewhere else.

Then and now, immigration has been a tumultuous subject in America, even as those waves of huddled masses passed beneath the shadow of the Statue of Liberty on Ellis Island. Witness the history in this country of the Irish, Poles, Italians and Russian Jews. Many of those same fears are being raised today about migrants from Latin America, Asia and Africa, who still see America as their best hope in the world.

The situation is further clouded by the chaos along the country’s southwestern border. As one RGJ reader wrote, “A country without regulated borders is no country at all.”

Things along the U.S.’s southern border do appear out of control and seem to be getting worse. In 2022 alone, it’s estimated 2.76 million immigrants, a number equal to the size of Chicago (our third-largest city), crossed the border illegally into the United States.

In taking on this topic, I’m painfully aware of how deeply the country’s partisan divide has paralyzed Congress. Members seem permanently gridlocked between intractable positions on “Dreamers” rights and border security issues. Recent U.S. presidents have also failed to lead on this issue, resorting to rhetoric and executive orders that get reversed as the political pendulum swings wildly back and forth. Leadership, as difficult as it may be, has been sorely lacking. Failure to solve the problem may be our undoing as a country if we don’t manage to comprehensively reform our immigration system.

Legal immigration is in our best interest. Illegal immigration is not.

Legal immigration done right can be a foundation for America’s continued success. As Daniel Griswold from the Cato Institute wrote, “Immigration is not undermining the American experiment; it is an integral part of it. We are a nation of immigrants. Successive waves of immigrants have kept our country demographically young, enriched our culture and added to our productive capacity as a nation, enhancing our influence in the world.”

The key to immigration has always been assimilation. The country’s good fortune has come from taking in immigrants and turning them into Americans. The goal of immigration is about newcomers integrating into society and then strengthening our culture and especially the economy. The longer immigrants have lived in the United States, the more “they” become “us.”

Illegal immigration places unworkable burdens on social services, schools and hospitals. Even New York and Chicago that once considered themselves “sanctuary cities” are discouraging undocumented immigrants from coming there.

President Bill Clinton in his 1995 State of the Union address said, “We are a nation of immigrants. But we are also a nation of laws. It is wrong and ultimately self-defeating for a nation of immigrants to permit the kind of abuse of our immigration laws we have seen in recent years, and we must do more to stop it.” Not many current Democrats appear to agree with their party’s one-time standard bearer. It’s a problem.

Amnesty was something even Republican President Ronald Reagan agreed to in his 1986 immigration reforms: “I believe that it is not enough, as I said, to tinker at the margins of U.S. immigration law … the United States must institute comprehensive reforms that conform to the realities of the era in which we live.” Not many Republicans, especially Donald Trump, appear to agree with the country’s most popular conservative. It’s also a problem.

Previously, America was described as a melting pot. The current analogy is closer to that of a salad bar. Regardless of any culinary imagery, as it was said in the 1960s, “you are what you eat.” It’ll be better for our digestion if our immigration consumption is intentional and well-planned.

Currently America’s economy needs more high-skilled workers. Given the demographic challenge of declining U.S. birthrates, younger immigrants, especially those who were educated in American universities, could fill a need that many businesses have and any future society would benefit from. Jessica Vaughan, director of policy studies for the Center of Immigration Studies, said of the recent wave of immigrants, “Those who are crossing the Rio Grande now are not necessarily the workers that a lot of employers are posting jobs on Indeed are looking for. We should reform our legal immigration system to address actual shortages to encourage the most highly skilled people in the world to come here.”

Our political parties have become a roadblock instead of a roadway to finding a solution to the immigration problem. Each side of the immigration debate appears self-satisfied they are right and other sides is decidedly wrong. The current chaos at our Texas border exemplifies how sharply divided we are as a nation.

A solution can happen when we have a change of heart and mind with regard to how we look at being Americans. Amy Chua, author of the book “Political Tribes,” suggests, “It’s not enough that we view one another as fellow human beings, we need to view one another as fellow Americans. .. of all sorts — old and young, immigrant and native born, urban and rural, descendants of slaves as well as descendants of slave owners.”

As a grandson of an Irish immigrant and a husband to a wife who is also from another country, I know America is stronger in our diversity, and better because of our differences. Immigration, planned for and legal, is in our best interest as a nation.

Out of the many, we can still become one in America.

Thanks to you all for your feedback at pathickey@dataclonemail.com. Sorry, no Irish need apply.

“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.

Memo from the Middle

Pat Hickey

Columnist

Reno Gazette Journal

Previously, America was described as

a melting pot.

The current analogy is closer to that of

a salad bar.