The Biblical story is told of the wisdom of Israel’s King Solomon when he ruled between the two women who both claimed to be the mother of a child. Solomon proposed cutting the baby in half. The first woman agreed to the compromise. The second woman begged Solomon to give the baby to her rival. Solomon ordered the child given to the second woman, who he judged to be the real mother because of her love and concern for the well-being of the baby.
Given all the divisions in the world, and within our own country, the question of peaceful co-existence is worth exploring now more than ever.
Israel’s leaders today face an even more difficult dilemma than Solomon in seeking how to deal with Hamas — the fundamentalist Islamic terrorist organization that crossed over the border from Gaza on Oct. 7, killing Jews, even murdering little children. Hamas fighters took infants hostage as they screamed for their mothers. According to documented accounts, they murdered old women, tormented and raped young women and burned people alive. Nothing figurative with these types. Mayhem and murder straight up. Tragically, it’s there for the world to see.
For someone who seeks to find the good between both sides of a dispute, it’s next to impossible to find common ground after Hamas’ attacks and the ensuing blood-stained sands. It’s harder yet to un-muddy the moral waters of a Mideast morass that is so frequently splattered with the remains of innocent victims.
Hamas’s own political charter proclaims: “Israel will exist … until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it.” As the self-proclaimed executioners in carrying out their religious holy war (Jihad), Hamas terrorists justify their killing of Jews and other “nonbelievers,” as something their fundamentalist beliefs mandate. While most Muslims don’t hold such archaic views, they have been unsuccessful in tempering the passions of the fervent extremists within their faith.
Hamas’ uncivilized views fly in the face of the modern Israel I know. The multi-ethnic, religiously tolerant democracy is a place I’ve visited with the owner of Reno’s Atlantis Resort, John Farahi, and his wife Catherine. John is a Jew who emigrated to the United States from Iran, when he foresaw the era of religious and political intolerance unfolding as the Islamic Revolution took over Tehran.
The Farahis’ tour of Israel included visits to the historic birthplaces in Jerusalem of three of the world’s great religions: Judaism, Christianity and Islam. We visited the holy sites of all three faiths and met persons of good will within each of the religious traditions. We even stayed overnight in the home of a Muslim family who had made their peace with Israel and were free to practice their faith freely without recrimination. We witnessed the performance of a circus troupe that was created between Palestinian and Israeli youth that required a level of trust on the trapeze wires that went beyond any dialogue at a conference table.
Visiting with John Farahi at the Atlantis this past week, the pain within him was palatable. Tearfully, he told me, “What Hamas did was medieval. Look at what they do to women and gay people in their own communities … They didn’t care what people’s individual beliefs were — they were just Jews.”
What Israel is going to do in the wake of these terror attacks is about to unfold. It could well trigger a larger war that could engulf the entire Mideast and most certainly bring the United States into the conflict. It’s quite possibly what Hamas and its puppet masters in Iran are hoping for. Israel was attacked in part because it was felt their political divisions made them vulnerable. They might be even more vulnerable if their actions in Gaza don’t succeed.
More than anytime in their 3,500-year history, Israel should seek the wisdom of Solomon. While it has every right and the duty to respond to an attack against its very existence, Israel must be prepared if a large-scale invasion and occupation of Gaza results in significant Israeli casualties and possibly even fails to eliminate Hamas. Of course, Israel needs to address their concerns of stability and security. They also will have to address humanitarian concerns if they are to win the battle of hearts and minds and maintain the moral high ground.
Raphael Cohen is a Rand Corp analyst on Mideast affairs. He advises, “Once all the killing is done, Israel will have to do something even harder if it’s to have any hope of preventing the next war and the one after that: It will need to rebuild Gaza into something better than it was.” Author Richard Haas, writing recently in the Wall Street Journal, said, “The focus should be on developing a Palestinian partner willing to renounce violence and live alongside Israel.”
Israel has made significant strides in building relationships with Egypt, Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries in recent years. They have accepted that Israel is a part of the Mideast neighborhood, with every right to exist — and even prosper, as they have. It’s time for neighbors to become friends and stop behaving like enemies. The very survival of both requires it.
A liberal RGJ reader frequently sends me articles that support the idea of “no justice, no peace!” It’s one those “chicken and egg” conundrums that is a powerful political slogan. Looking at the recent injustices carried out by Hamas in the name of justice, I’ve come to the conclusion that a better way to look at the problem is “no good will, no peace.” Good will is something both sides will have to adhere to — if they want either justice or peace. India’s Prime Minister Indira Gandhi said it best: “You cannot shakes hands with a clenched fist.”
Neither can Israel defeat Hamas by military power alone. History is replete with resentments and the residual remains of the past. We can either dwell on the past with clenched fists, or extend a hand seeking forgiveness and reconciliation.
Jerusalem is the cradle of three of the world’s great religions. They each believe in the same source of the world. As a cradle, they should give birth to world peace, not be the crypt for the death of it.
It will take the wisdom of a Solomon — or at least those who are willing to bring Israel together with responsible Arab players (not the barbaric members of Hamas) — to determine what a just resolution is. Only then will there ever be peace.
I welcome your thoughts: tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
“Memo from the Middle” is an opinion column written by RGJ columnist Pat Hickey, a member of the Nevada Legislature from 1996 to 2016.
