On the same day I was first elected to the Nevada Assembly in 1996, Nevada voters approved a constitutional amendment to enact term limits for a number of elected officials in Nevada, including members of the State Legislature. The provisions specified a lifetime 12-year limit on assembly members and senators, beginning with the general election in 1998.

Limiting how long members can serve in Carson City promised to increase fiscal responsibility, bring in new ideas and perspectives, and reduce corruption in the Capitol.

Given the current levels of citizen dissatisfaction with the political process, it would seem the presumed panacea of term limits hasn’t exactly delivered on its impassioned promises.

‘Throw the bums out’ — along with their experience?

Opponents at the time to systematically boot the bums out, warned that limiting the longevity of members legislative service would likely result in an increase in lobbyist and staff influence, create a “revolving door” effect, and increase party polarization. They argued that legislative leaders will not remain in office long enough to forge relationships with their counterparts in the other party, resulting in the kind of government gridlock witnessed today that frustrates so many voters.

A recent study by University of Chicago Center for Effective Government concluded the same: “Term limits causes legislators to lose influence relative to staff, bureaucrats and governors and to become less professional, less innovative and less specialized.” Also, “State legislative term limits increase polarization between elected officials.”

Singer-songwriter Carole King bemoaned in her 1970s ballad “So Far Away,” why “doesn’t anybody stay in one place anymore?” At the time term limits took effect, Governor Kenny Guinn was an opponent of term limits and was a proponent of leadership that had lasting values along with a lasting stay in public office. Quoted in Michael Archer’s book on long-serving State Senator Bill Raggio, “A Man of His Word,” Guinn said; “You just cannot fund projects one year and not the next. It takes a long time to replace someone with Bill Raggio’s experience.”

Republican Raggio served a total of 39 years in the State Senate in Nevada. His political counterpart in leadership, Democrat Joe Dini, served a total of 34 years in the State Assembly. Along with being political adversaries, they formed a lifelong friendship based on mutual respect and acceptance that resulted in legislative sessions where both parties got parts of what they wanted and political bipartisanship was neither a dirty word nor a distant reality.

Nowhere to prep for the ‘big leagues’

State Senator Randolph Townsend served during the pre-term limit days. The Republican was even asked to chair a commerce committee by Democratic leadership because of his earned legislative expertise.

“There’s no Triple-A ball club to produce Nevada lawmakers for the big leagues of Carson City.” Townsend recently told me. “With term limits in place and the absence of institutional memories in the minds and experiences of most Nevada lawmakers, the lobbyists and the Legislative Counsel Bureau become the dominant source of information for lawmakers.”

Townsend says it takes a lawmaker years to become someone who can become a good leader: “Once you learn to tell your friends ‘no,’ then you become a statesman.”

Not an easy thing to do as Bill Raggio learned in his later legislative years when many “friends” in his own party turned against him.

Having seen firsthand the leadership of Joe Dini and Bill Raggio in their heyday in 1997 when I first served in office, and in Raggio’s swan song when I returned in 2011, I saw two giants who valued the legislative process over their individual stature. The respect they had for each other translated into a message to newly-elected lawmakers — that the institution in which you serve is greater than the persons who get elected to serve in it.

I recently attended The Nevada Independent event panels with Nevada’s governor and legislative leadership, where both confided to the audience that they infrequently speak with each other until the end of a contentious session. It reminded me of how divided we have become as a society and how little of personal relationships elected folks in Carson City actually have with each other.

With a combined 73 years of serving together in Carson City, that was obviously not a problem for Joe Dini and Bill Raggio.

Townsend told me back in the day he played racquetball with his committee members of both parties after meetings before going to dinner afterwards on most nights.

Term limits are the law. The public supports the idea in spite of all the unintended consequences that I’ve pointed out. So what’s the answer?

Staying for 12 years in either the State Senate or State Assembly (or both), as some have, is an adequate time to form commitments and make relationships than can result in effective lawmaking and the kind of statesmanship Sen. Townsend suggested.

Legislature shouldn’t be a stepping stone

Too many current lawmakers see their arrival in the Capitol as the first in many steps to higher-paying careers in other offices or in the lobbying world that welcomes many. It’s why I passed an Assembly bill in 2015 that required a one-year “cooling-off period” for ex-lawmakers before they could lobby the Nevada Legislature.

Possibly, if being a “citizen legislator” didn’t result in a full-time responsibility with a part-time paycheck; serving in the Legislature might attract persons committed to making a career in the legislative arena, as Nevadans once did in the past. Term limits may limit the stay of certain lawmakers — but as has been pointed out, the surest term limit of all is the ballot box for those who don’t live up to voter’s expectations.

While term limits have been implemented in Nevada and other states generating a great deal of debate, their effectiveness in achieving the goals of proponents is a matter of ongoing discussion and research. There is no universal consensus on whether they have led to the positive changes that were hoped for, with some research suggesting mixed or even negative results.

Nevadans need strong leadership if we want to be an effective state. As author Eric Weiner points out in “The Socrates Express,” “We think we want information and knowledge. We do not. We want wisdom.” Wisdom comes from experience and legislators especially, can only provide that sort of wise leadership if they stay long enough and are committed to bipartisan values.

Having been mentored by Bill Raggio on both occasions I was freshman lawmaker in Carson City (whether he always knew it or not), I was shocked when the senator told me it took him 20 years to understand Nevada’s budget. I thought at the time, what hope would there be for lesser mortals like myself?

It was why when I was offered the chairmanship of the Assembly’s Ways and Means (money) Committee during my last term in office, I declined in favor of someone who would be staying longer than I could.

Another legislative session is coming to a close. Nevada needs a new generation of legislative leaders who will think statewide, and who can act in a nonpartisan manner when the good of the state requires it.

We need lawmakers who will make a commitment to serving, if not as long as Joe Dini and Bill Raggio; but with the same passion to partner with their counterparts and even become friends with their onetime foes.

As always — I appreciate hearing your thoughts at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.