It is the classic story of bad things happening to someone trying to do good. Like the Old Testament tale that befell the tragic biblical figure of Job; students and staff at the federally funded Sierra Nevada Job Corps seem about to lose everything. It’s turning into a test of faith of how much our government can do to bridge the opportunity gap for a growing number of American youth who are falling through society’s ever-widening cracks.

The Trump administration’s current budget doesn’t include funding for the 60-year old workforce training program for 16-24 year olds who have grown up primarily in poverty and dropped out of traditional high schools. I was told by Job Corps staff that two-thirds of the boarding school students housed at the former Stead Air Force Base come from southern Nevada.

Job Corps has its share of success stories, including heavyweight boxing campion George Foreman, who joined the program as a troubled youth and eventually found a path to success in both boxing and business.

Rocky Flanary is Sierra Nevada Job Corps Center’s director. He’s been on the Stead campus for 35 years since graduating from UNR where he was the manager of the Wolf Pack’s men’s basketball program. Working his way up to his present position, Rocky says, “I’ve seen so many kids lives change that have come to Job Corps and left for good-paying jobs.”

The day I visited Stead, the sadness was palpable on the faces of students and staff upon hearing news that the Department of Labor is asking for kids to be sent home. Rocky and longtime teachers and staffers like Donne Levy and Leslie Mix appeared to be crushed like old Job was — uncertain why what they’ve loved so dearly is so suddenly “being taken away.”

Students too, seemed at a loss, with one of them saying, “So many of my friends did not finish high school. I gave Job Corps a chance, was doing good in the cement trade and now we were told that the program is going away. Not sure what I’m going to do now.”

Are programs like Job Corps sustainable?

A series of audits, studies and investigations — public and private — starting in the late 1990s, and extending through to the early 2020s, has cast doubt on the safety and cost-effectiveness of the program, and have brought calls for the program’s end. The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) has consistently warned about many programs: “The federal government is on an unsustainable long-term fiscal path that poses serious economic, national security, and social challenges if not addressed.”

Job Corps also has been challenged for its lack of return on the federal investment with Labor Department statistics revealing a low national graduation rate at 39%. President Trump recently called Job Corps a “failed experiment,” saying that the per-student cost each year — estimated at $80,000 annually — is not a good use of taxpayer money.

The only chance of Job Corps’ survival is in the Republican-led U.S. Senate. It happened once before when the hope of a “Hail Mary pass” that Rocky Flanary is praying for took place when U.S. Senator Orin Hatch of Utah played a crucial role in saving Job Corps during the Reagan administration when there were attempts to eliminate the program then. Still, at a time when the Unites States is facing a severe crisis of deficit spending, the GAO and others are saying, “The longer we wait to act, the more dire the consequences will be on the economy and the public.”

Is there a better model?

Like Job’s friends who watched his difficult plight and did the right thing by coming to him when he was suffering, empathizing with his situation, and spending time listening and commiserating with their friend — some supporters wonder if there something different that can be done for these kids than the current Job Corps model. Is there a better and more sustainable way to address the problems of poverty-stricken youth and their chronic underachievement in society?

Visiting the Job Corps campus this past week, I was surprised to learn that, as reported in the RGJ, there are a total “staff of about 170,” providing the wrap-around services and needs of somewhere between 200-300 students. This means that a residential living and training program like Job Corps requires one staff member for every one and a half students enrolled in the program. Apply that number nationally to the over 11 million children in the U.S. living in poverty, according to the Kids Count Data Center, and we would be talking about millions of more federal employees to address such problems in this matter. Can we really afford a program that costs $80,000 a year to house and train students who have dropped out of high school, or is there a better and more sustainable way?

Why not more vocational high schools?

Nevada’s most recent school funding numbers approved by the Legislature and the signed by the governor includes almost $14,000 of per-pupil funding (not including federal dollars). Wouldn’t it be wiser to spend more money on construction trade schools like ACE Charter High School or WCSD’s Career and Technical Education programs like AACT, or the new Debbi Smith CTE Academy? That is, would make more sense to fund trade and vocational opportunities for students before they drop out, rather than have to spend immeasurable amounts of money for kids who don’t see a way forward for their future?

As one Job Corps member recently posted on a blog following the announcement the program may close: “Society needs to start holding parents accountable and schools need to be offering these kids hope.”

Robert Putnam, in his book “Our Kids — The American Dream in Crisis,” quoted economist Isabel Sawhill about the need for a new mindset regarding parenting: “Too many young adults are sliding into relationships and having babies before they are ready to make commitments to each other and to their children that parenthood requires.” Putnam agreed, saying, “Changing the norm from childbearing by default to childbearing by design might have a big effect on the opportunity gap.”

A long road to recovery eventually unfolded for the troubled figure Job. Before his good fortune was restored, he went through quite the ordeal. So, too, might the lives of the students and staff of Nevada’s Job Corps be somehow renewed or rewarded after quite the ordeal of their own. The closure, while indeed being a hard pill for students to swallow, is an even harder one to administer for the caring people who have been serving these kids for all these years.

Miracles can happen, but not always in the time frame we may expect, as Job learned. Valor can be found not only on a nation’s battlefields. People like Rocky and the staff and teachers of apprenticeships for Nevadans will likely find other employment with far greater wages in the private sector. The kids, though, are another matter.

To truly help them, we all may need to learn the patience of Job. In times of uncertainty, let’s hope we find new and better ways to support the children who need us the most.

Like Job, we may even have to learn the hard way to believe that bad things don’t have to destroy good people or all the good we try to do.

Your thoughts? Email me at tahoeboy68@gmail.com.

Your Turn