It was unanimous. The vote on The vote on the Declaration of Independence by the thirteen colonies that became the United States. It was in effect a shutdown of a government that no longer worked.
As we prepare to celebrate our 250th birthday as a nation next year — the thought of any vote in Congress being unanimous in the current divided circumstances — may seem as far off as landing on the moon once did.
And yet, after the heated and contentious debates were completed in 1776, America’s founders concluded, in the now famous words to break from the past: “When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another…it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government.”
Those early Americans decided to change the government that no longer worked for them and leave it behind in favor of a better system. Possibly, it’s time for us to do the same.
The founders gave us permission, and even urged us to alter, or abolish the way we are being governed when government no longer ensures our “Safety and Happiness.”
As a moderate who writes a “Memo from the Middle,” I certainly agree with the signers of the Declaration of Independence that “Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes.”
Government shutdowns
should make us think
After going through the twentieth government shutdown in the last forty-nine years, it’s time to ask ourselves the question: “What’s wrong with the way our current Federal government in Washington, D.C., is doing things?”
While Congress is divided and dickering over whether their respective political bases will applaud or napalm their politically motivated antics, at least members of Congress and the president still receive their salaries because they are part of a permanent appropriation.
Not so for most government employees. Furloughs, unpaid essential workers, threatened agency layoffs and reduced agency operations, and eventually travel, can be affected when shutdowns continue for very long.
According to a recent Wall Street Journal editorial about the how government shutdowns result in a breakdown of trust by the American people, “Washington’s current dysfunction is a reflection of a broader, nationwide revulsion against America’s political system. Nearly two-thirds of voters believe the nation is too divided to address its problems, a recent New York Times poll found. Nearly 80% in a Quinnipiac University survey agreed with the statement that the nation is in a political crisis.”
Government shutdowns hurt the perception the public has about both Democrats and Republicans.
The Sept. 27 New York Times/Siena poll found that 65% of voters surveyed agree with the statement: “Democrats should not shut down the government, even if their demands are not met.” The net result of the shutdown will probably be to weaken further the public’s perceptions of the Democratic Party, already in the tank.
Republicans, who are in control of both the White House and Congress, should be challenged by voters: “Why,” if they are in control, they can’t get the job done? Republican strategist and onetime Nevadan, Karl Rove, says there aren’t any winners when the government continuously shuts down: “It’s a staggering display of ineptitude from a Congress that can’t pass a budget and can’t even agree to keep the government funded at roughly its current spending level while the parties work out differences.”
How democracies die
The last time these United States were so divided was in the 1850s. It led us into the Civil War. Abraham Lincoln lost a U.S. Senate race in 1858 over the divisive issue of slavery. It was during one such debate with Stephen A. Douglas that Lincoln gave his now-famous “House Divided” speech, quoting Christ. Foretelling a great reckoning coming to America, Lincoln predicted: “In my opinion, it (our conflicts) will not cease until a crisis shall have been reached and passed. A house divided against itself cannot stand.”
The root of our current crisis in America is the deepening divisions in the political climate of the country. The proof in the pudding, is in the seemingly never-ending hostility and transience that both Republicans and Democrats exhibit toward one another. It filters down to the public. People do as they see their leaders do.
As political columnist Ezra Klein has written, “As political institutions and actors become more polarized, they further polarize the public.” And as authors Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt write in their book “How Democracies Die,” “When societies divide into partisan camps with profoundly different worldviews, and those differences are viewed as existential and irreconcilable, political rivalry can devolve into partisan hatred. Parties come to view each other not as legitimate rivals but as dangerous enemies.”
Sadly, it’s what America is becoming. Another government shutdown is merely evidence of the fact.
Democracy is the sum of its parts
In a democratic republic like ours, where representative democracy requires trust between those who are elected, and those who do the electing — we are stronger when we are united. Differences like the kind that exist between men and women, who become mothers and fathers, become a complement not a detriment to the well-being of children. The same holds true in our political system. Yes — it requires the “dirtiest of all” political words: compromise. That’s how functioning families work. Why not let it be the remedy that helps our splintering political system work as well?
Social scientist and author Robert Putnam offers up in his latest book “The Upswing,” “The promotion of one’s own interests at the expense of others has created an environment of relentless zero-sum competition in a repeated failure of compromise.” Progressive Republican President Teddy Roosevelt said as much: “The fundamental rule of our national life — the rule which underlies all others — is that, on the whole, and in the long run, we shall go up or down together.”
Nevada can show the way
Being a Nevadan, I’m hopeful. Nevada voters have a long and well-known history of being “ticket-splitters,” with recent elections showcasing the trend even as partisan divisions have deepened nationally. This behavior, where voters select candidates from different parties for different offices on the same ballot, has created divided government and made the state a key electoral battleground.
I’m encouraged by younger Nevada leaders like Zelalem Bogale, an adjunct professor of political science and criminal justice at the University of Nevada, Reno, who says, “The Founders foresaw factions, but not the kind of party-over-institution inversion we see today. The media and algorithmic social media may lead us to believe that the chasm in politics is between Democrats and Republicans — I think that’s wrong. The political chasm today is between what Democrats think Republicans believe and what Republicans think Democrats believe. On some of the most important issues, the vast majority of us are on Team America, not team red or blue.”
The fact that nonpartisan and independent voters in Nevada now outnumber the older political parties is encouraging. It will take impressive, electable independent candidates to one day break the stranglehold the two traditional parties have on the process.
It’s young Nevadans like Zelalem who give me hope that, “in the course of human events,” we’ll have people who step up and give us the confidence to bet on the future like our founders did.
What say you? tahoeboy68@gmail.com.
